I also don't why you think the doctor was giving false hope, or being less than candid. I think it is pretty clear that the author knows phase 1 studies are not well characterized and or proven effective.
I also don't why you think the doctor was giving false hope, or being less than candid. I think it is pretty clear that the author knows phase 1 studies are not well characterized and or proven effective.
Second: regardless of what the author understands or does not, the quotes about oncologists pointing to their favorite trial, and the like, are not OK. The only valid answer is "we don't know", because literally every drug candidate in a phase 1 trial has some claim to plausibility outside of humans, yet most fail.
However, they should be clear on what is option vs established consensus
But do those opinions have any scientific basis? If there isn’t any evidence of efficacy yet, then should a doctor say there is because it’s his or her opinion?
However, rat studies, theory, experience, ect are all evidence.
If you are navigating uncharted territory, your should listen to the opinion of your local guide. "I don't like that drug because every one of my patients that took it died horrible deaths" might not mean much statistically, but if there isn't any other data, I would want to know. Same if my doctor thinks a treatment is crazy and will never succeed.