Isn't this just stating the obvious? I think the same would be true no matter who it was or what was said. Indeed nobody would feel the need to discuss something if we were all in agreement already. I don't think people should necessarily fault someone merely for having an opinion that differs from yours, which IMO is exactly what this letter is about, and I don't even see what opinions are actually different to be honest.
> Thought the inclusion of the word "formal" here was was pretty funny.
Not sure why, you don't give any reasoning, but ok.
> choosing to simply deny every single thing
I didn't get that from their response at all. It sounds to me like the open letter should have listed specific action items they wanted to see, if they wanted to be taken seriously.
> Even if he did nothing wrong at all
Doesn't this by definition mean he doesn't need to do anything else? I'm confused.
> he makes no attempt to reach out to people
Which people where? Who was wronged and how? Where was that documented? I don't understand how you can expect someone to "reach out" to invisible people who won't make their concerns heard clearly (this letter is not that IMO).
> He doesn't seem to comprehend that one can try, but fail
Same as above... I don't see where specific wrongdoing is called out, or any suggestions for improvement.
> this has done enough to turn me off it
What is "this"? How has this directly affected you? To me there is no "this" or even a "him" without very specific concerns called out.