It is true that a NAT could give you some privacy, but the downside is also very obvious. For example, your network neighbor might rub some service in the wrong way, then the service ended up sanction/ban the shared NAT exit.
Then, you might be thinking, "just use a smaller CGNAT then". Well, then a smaller CGNAT will allow the website to track you more easily.
If I really really don't want to be tracked, I'd rather use Tor.