> Around a decade ago, a teenager who couldn’t be saved was admitted to a New England hospital. Like Shania Arms, he had cystic fibrosis. A previous lung transplant was failing, and his only hope was another transplant. He was put on ecmo while he waited. Two months later, doctors discovered that he had developed an incurable cancer. Now there was no way for him to leave the I.C.U. His lungs were beyond recovery, and the cancer made him ineligible for transplant. He was caught on a bridge to nowhere.
> Some members of the medical team thought that ecmo should be stopped. Transplant was no longer possible, and ecmo machines were scarce. As long as the patient was on the machine, it couldn’t be used to save someone else. It’s also expensive; according to a 2023 study, the median hospitalization charge for covid patients on ecmo was around eight hundred and seventy thousand dollars, and prolonged cases can exceed several million. These resources might be needed to help other patients, and the boy couldn’t live in the I.C.U. indefinitely.
> But others on the team disagreed. “He was texting with his friends,” Robert Truog, a pediatrician and bioethicist who was involved with and wrote about the case in The Lancet, said. He was spending time with family, and doing homework online. Because he could be awake on ecmo, he could still engage in activities that were meaningful. Situations like this represent a “profound ethical dilemma,” Raghu Seethala, an intensivist and ecmo specialist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, told me. “The technology is ahead of the ethics,” another expert said.
The technology isn't "ahead of the ethics" as the one quote indicates. This is a simple case of some people apparently advocating for killing a living, conscious, interacting-with-the-world teenager because he wouldn't just hurry up and die, and they want to use his resources for something else.
I bet those same people would learn that over 80% of people aged 70-75 reside in a home they own, and immediately come up with a modest proposal for how to solve the housing crisis.