Classical Music for Beginners
taleofgenji.org
taleofgenji.org
The choice of artists is interesting. It’s a matter of taste of course, but I think a more “neutral” reading of some of these concerti would be better. Perlman’s portamento shifts are indulgent; and Anne-Sophie Mutter’s tone comes across as strident even when a something more subdued is called for. For example for the Brahms violin concerto, James Ehnes is a better choice for an honest reading. The second movement in his hands is lovely without the drippy sentimentality into which Perlman can lapse.
If you can't, it's Haydn.
And if it sounds angry, it's Beethoven.
But a real objection would be the writer's assertion that Baroque is less suited for beginners. Just listen to some concerti grossi from the Italian masters (Albinoni, the Marcellos, Corelli, and such) and you'll be, I think, easily convinced otherwise.