So you give it back to the shareholders, and a buyback is tax advantaged for the shareholders compared to a dividend.
* if you are, say, Pepsi, and you have a very good year, you might want to “bank” some or all of those profits for a lean year or for some future investment. But the CFO doesn’t put $10B in a bank account, they invest it. If they put 10B into Apple it won’t have any legal implications (Apple is so huge) and it’s probably a better return than anything else available.
But when you are Apple the sums are so huge and the choice of places you can invest so limited, that giving it back to the shareholders and letting them decide is pretty much your only option. A good problem to have.
Other than that, maybe R&D? Even if Apple were known as an R&D company (and they haven't been known for that since Jobs returned and among other things got rid of ATG), probably wouldn't even need that kind of cash to run.
But there's diminishing returns, at some point the ROI for the next candidate investment isn't good enough to make it a valid choice over a buyback or dividend.
They licensed a design from ARM, tweaked it, and sent it to TSMC to manufacture it.
At this point, probably the main benefit of the ARM license is just the patents.
Apple has a longstanding relationship with ARM back to the latter’s founding. The sale of its large chunk of ownership in ARM helped Apple survive in its late-90s reboot. So it’s quite possible that their license is quite different from those of the few other hardware licensees.
Also, Apple plays the long game. I’m sure they also have a lot of RISC-V experience by now. Not just weirdo in-house research products; I’d be shocked if there weren’t tiny RISC-V cores doing small housekeeping tasks inside some of their huge chips, just for the experience. Maybe even a few inside an Apple pencil or maybe an ipad screen digitizer since the computation isn’t really user visible.
As does ARM: if RISC-V ever becomes airborne (it’s still speeding down the runway) I suspect ARM will haul out a stack of patents and start demanding payment. Apple’s license surely covers them here.
Seriously though, people decrying this as financial engineering seem, to me, to be completely missing the point. It's not the purpose of a firm to endlessly expand their business until they do everything. It's to do the thing they are good at, what they have a comparative advantage over the rest of the industry over, and then instead of chasing ever worse roi on ever more marginal investment and research, return the rest of the money to the investors so they can make their own choices on what to invest on.
I think that is fallacious thinking. Apple tried hard with the Newton but larger, infrastructure pieces were not yet in place. Meta has tried hard with VR but there is no evidence that a large population even wants this tech.
Apart from AI, we may simply be in an innovation desert for the consumer tech companies. Things like the portable digital music player, smart phone, might only come every decade or so — and no amount of R&D will force that to behave any differently.
Crazy thought but I know one larger entity to park the money in and it's the US treasury. Apple has no positioning to improve things like infrastructure and public education.
Stock buybacks should be a clear signal that taxes can go up at that bracket of the economy.
While this is true, investors would generally rather have the money returned to them so they may diversify their portfolios as they see fit instead of letting the company do it for them. (at least for spherical cow investors)
The common example for this is for non liquid shares that you can’t really sell.
In this case, the profits on the shares "aren't realised until you sell them", so it's not real profits, but somehow you can use them as collateral to get a loan and grow your total wealth - without spending a penny or even having to get a job. In that case, I think if you're using shares as collateral, the profits on those shares should be taxable.
That's precisely what this is. It's financially prudent for a company with this much cash to buy back their stock when it's (relatively) cheap. It also doubles as signaling to the market. It's cheaper and better than issuing dividends.
In addition to accounting/reporting, the CFO's job is to decide if/where to spend capital and if/how/when to return it to shareholders.
Buying back stock when the price drops is not really financial engineering—it's just finance, period.
Should they spend it on an acquisition when most large acquisitions fail to add positive value?
Even if they could find an attractive large acquisition target, some regulator somewhere in the world is going to block it.