It’s not. But it’s clear the industry needs supervision, and it isn’t really worth the time drafting federal legislation. The SEC keeping the most egregious behaviour checked, e.g. policing positioning with retail investors, is the best worst option for now.
The way these businesses are run, it probably does too. A good amount of effort in finance goes into avoiding unneeded regulatory duplication. But if you’re a you’re a bank you get both the FDIC and SEC, a public drug manufacturer the SEC and FDA; if you’re selling crypto through your brokerage app, the SEC and CFTC.
Why not? Mixed swaps are dual regulated, for instance [1].
[1] https://katten.com/CFTC-SEC-Finalize-Swap-Product-Definition...
The point is enforcement. We ban weapons in some areas despite murder being illegal.
Anyone who was working at Coinbase during the rise of Binance or FTX can tell you everybody knew they were playing outside the rules. Once you know how hard it is to do things right, it's easy to see when some upstart flies in and starts gobbling up market share that they're cutting corners.
It took 7 years for Binance and CZ to get fined like they finally did. FTX might even still be operating if SBF hadn't panicked and filed for bankruptcy. Riding those guys out was one of Coinbase's major challenges, and competitors who didn't have established market share and teams couldn't even effectively enter the market and compete with those players.
Regulation often sounds like a good idea to honest people, but it doesn't account for the reality that many people don't care at all about playing by anybody else's rules.
To be clear, I don't know or really care if these stupid things are securities or what. But I do know that you're going to need a lot better of an argument than an "um actshually" to get the Feds off your ass. Y'all went and achieved your dream: a parallel financial system. Now Uncle Sam's comin' to get his cut.
Agree with most of your comment, just to say that this was not the goal as originally described by Nakamoto, but rather an ex-post justification for crypto when it blatantly failed in reaching the specific goals it set out to achieve.