Exactly, we can't speculate on what they did in their 20s. All we can do is go from what they said, which was basically "We can't justify moving because we'd have to get a mortgage at a much higher rate". I don't think that's uncommon. I have plenty of friends that bought with 2% interest rates, and they wouldn't be able to afford the places they got with 7% rates. It's also not uncommon for people to be in their 40s and 50s without owning a place in NYC, I have plenty of friends also in that boat.
And yeah I've been in BK for almost 20 years now, I remember hanging out in Williamsburg in 2000 when I was in college, it wasn't that bad. I actually prefer the old version of it to what it is now. Sure, it wasn't the Los Sures of the 80s by the time I got here, but it was a lot more fun. I only had my life threatened once and we deescalated quickly!