I’ve had consistently good experiences with Turo so far. Once it gets bigger it will probably go downhill, but currently the hosts remind me of AirBNB hosts from around 2013. Like normal people who are actually trying to do a good job. I haven’t had any issues though so not sure if they handle dispute resolution or damage well.

What would it take for you to trust them, or what was your bad experience? I had a bad experience with GetAround with their reservation time math code logic was bad and wouldn't let me rent a car a midnight despite the car being available.