Couldn't the higher-end / more expensive places just put their prices up by x% the same as a low-end place?
Is the fear that if both cheap and expensive places moved tipping to higher prices (as an example let's say every single restaurant just raised menu prices by 15%) then more people would choose to go cheaper than do in the current situation of not thinking about accurate total cost until it comes to paying the tip after the meal?
I know we all have cognitive biases so it's possible something like that would be the case, but from a purely logical point of view it seems that if people are happy to pay $500 per person for a meal and to tip $100 on top of that, then they should also be happy to pay $600 for a meal that doesn't need tipping, just the same as for meals that cost $15, and I feel that if it were a universal change (ie not just a single restaurant announcing "no tipping here" but a national or at least state-wide law) then there wouldn't be a huge amount of people chenging from visiting expensive to cheap places.
> "winners and losers if we switched systems, as with any change"
With many, even most, changes that's literally a requirement of the change - with tax changes that keep the total tax revenue the same you have to have some paying more in order to have others paying less. Or if the change is to raise more total tax revenue to fund more social benefits, some tax payers need to pay more in order for some people to get more help. Etc.
But in this case the only losers would come from other people acting on illogical cognitive biases (with the exception of people who currently choose not to tip, or to undertip, who would then be forced to pay the real amount - but surely those people aren't a significant lobbying group, not a sympathetic group that others feel need protecting). Unless I'm missing some part of the equation and there is actually a reason higher-end place for necessarily do worse under a system where tips are included in the sticker price?