Las Vegas is a great recent example of too much over-optimistic growth being followed by a devastating bust and urban decay.
Las Vegas is a great recent example of too much over-optimistic growth being followed by a devastating bust and urban decay.
1) urban sprawl, which means
2) more land being used inefficently (wasted) and
3) more hours of life commuting (wasted), which leads to
4) more need for cars, leading to
5) more hours in congestion (wasted)
6) poorer people getting the worst of those points above, making
7) building public transport even more political feasable, while
8) public transport is the least efficient in low-density areas (wasted)
One could say that the decay of Detroit is at least contained in terms of space. Also, just because a bust is to be expected, it doesn't mean that people should be deprived of Jobs that never come to existance due to handicapped growth.
Low density is what made the emptying so contagious and the costs so unsustainable. Low density requires continual growth to pay for the long utility runs and the long service routes for everything from busses to police patrols to trash pickup. And because service erodes as buildings empty, more buildings empty. And when the remaining 20 or 30% of your population is scattered, it's very hard to introduce new businesses or retrench old ones to serve them. The erosion is almost impossible to contain without Flint-style abandoning of large swaths of area and relocation programs for anyone who remains. (Detroit has been trying similar, but it's expensive and slow.)
I don't know much about SF and the valley and I'll refrain from commenting there. But you guys know demonstrably nothing about Detroit and you may want to follow the example.
Of course, it takes money to attract new people to a city, but I think it can be done if the cost of doing business (i.e., cheap office space, business taxes, access to skilled labor, etc.) is attractive.