Buddhist Reincarnation Led to Hopelessness
worldviewsummit.org
worldviewsummit.org
The author is a Christian, so I suspect the purpose of this blog post is simply to denigrate Buddhism in the name of Christian apologetics, but that isn't compelling when you don't even put in the effort to understand the basics of what you're trying to denounce.
And besides, the Christian constructs of original sin and eternal damnation seem far more bleak than the Buddhist model. At least with Buddhism, your own personal morality and effort have some liminal value (as opposed to Christianity, where only faith in Christ can save you, and regardless of your morality or virtues you burn in hell by default) and there is always the opportunity for growth and renewal in another life (versus "it is destined for man to die once, and face judgement.")
(true, Dante isn't church-canonical, but he's certainly in the fanon, and no one in his first circle is burning)
I was just pointing out that from a certain point of view, the Christian model can look a lot more hopeless than Buddhism.
>I began to see that if Buddhism were correct then unless I attained enlightenment (nirvana) or something like it in this life, where the whole cycle of rebirth would finally come to a complete end, I would have no hope. Clearly, I was not going to attain enlightenment in this life. All Buddhists would be inclined to accept that as true concerning just about everyone. Enlightenment is a supreme and extremely rare achievement for spiritual heroes, not the likes of us – certainly not the likes of me. So I (and all my friends and family) have in themselves no hope.
So in short, the [Buddhist] ideal has not been tried and found wanting. It has been found difficult; and left untried.
Ending the cycle of rebirth mostly just means forestalling the reemergence of the ego/self/subject. It doesn't truly end, though I might grant that some extremely talented meditators can probably spend more time than not (but not all the time) in an egoless state. Take everything you read about the Buddha and his teachings as an attempt to articulate an empirical approach to dealing with the fact(s) of consciousness. If you can't find a way to make a certain lesson or articulation align with an empirical approach to consciousness, then just try a different lesson. The goal isn't nirvana, but freedom. Including freedom from goal-oriented perspectives.
It is unfortunate that this gentleman needed so long to spot this fundamental tenet of Buddhism.