> This is sad that the article goes on to explaining the crucial importance of smokes, flashbangs, etc while not focusing on them for analyzing games.
There are several layers here and I should write a follow-up article to discuss that because I realise now I was stuck in my mental context too much to explain the bigger picture in the article.
This article is not, strictly speaking, trying to explain performance; it tries to explain the Leetify rating which is hopefully a fair proxy for performance. Nor is it really about giving details on how to achieve a high rating -- that requires the things you mention to put oneself in position for a favourable engagement. (In fact, one can think of the kill itself as a proxy for several other things, such as successful flashbang usage.)
This article focuses entirely on one specific kill-or-get-killed decision. It took that much analysis to provide a useful guide for that decision alone! A more complicated set of decisions I don't even know how to approach quantitatively.
Like, how would you define a successful smoke, if you had to do it based on anything that does not boil down to community feels?
I'll look into scope.gg (and tracker.gg mentioned elsewhere in this discussion) and see if I can be inspired to analyse other decisions. Thanks again!