I believe that they never fully recovered after Covid and tourism never bounced back. The YEN has also taken a beating so you can get more for your USD.
Also, it's hard to directly compare stuff on shelves to what we have here. For example, Japanese peaches are much more expensive than Ontario peaches - but they are also incomparably better. However, if you only look at the price on the label, you would be rightfully shocked at the price difference.
(They are very good though)
How long back does your 'always' go?
Japan has approximately the same local price level now that they had in the early 1990s. One USD also buys approximately the same number of Yen as it did in the early 1990s. But the USD had quite a lot inflation in the meantime.
Ie Japan has gotten a lot cheaper comparatively. It used to be a lot more expensive.
Tourism bounced back as soon as they opened the borders. The 2023 numbers were at 2016/2017 level despite them not opening their borders until late 2022 (meaning lower ski-season numbers), and removing covid checks in April 2023.
Feb 2024 was reported as having 7% more tourists than Feb 2019 (2019 having peak tourism numbers).
There are a LOT of tourists at the moment.
For years it has been 1 USD = 110 JPY.
Japan is also overrun by tourists right now.