No? At most we're a continent of mostly social democracies. The workers don't own the means of production here in general, although cooperatives can be quite strong here. We also have way stronger labour unions than those in the US, for example (although funnily enough, in some ways that distances us from socialist republics since those tended to have the habit of banning labour unions, ironically enough), but these things don't make our countries socialist in nature.
Personally, I come from a Nordic country (Finland). Now, some American socialist pundits and politicians, like Bernie Sanders rather famously, tried to argue that the Nordic model is socialist and that we're socialist countries. They'd be wrong on that. While welfare states, we also explicitly have free market economies, which was even brought up by the Danish prime minister after the Sanders comments in 2015 in direct response to the latter. And in general, many people here would probably even be slightly offended by calling us socialists, or at least confused by it. And I think that this would also be the case for people in other parts of Europe, and especially those who were on the Eastern Bloc.
In Europe, in general, we do lean towards social-aware capitalism, which is still a far cry from a socialist republic. I know, I lived in one.
That’s a hard question, I don’t think there are any examples of long-lasting socialist societies of substantial size that have stayed particularly true to the purported ideology.
If we think about social democracy instead, I believe you’d have to cultivate those values in the population, if they’re not there already, as well as a high level of social trust.
I think that the criticism that was pointed to isn't really addressed by saying that others have a little bit of oligarchs too.
The level of centralisation of economic power we see in the USA today seems pretty unique in history (EDIT: even when compared to the similar sized economy of the EU). And I think that is something worthwhile discussing and thinking about.
Do you think economic power in, say 1200 in Europe was less centralized than in the USA today, or more?
Is economic power in the USA more centralized than it was in the Gilded Age?
If you wanted to claim that the level of centralization in the USA today was higher than in the last 100 years in most of the west, I could buy that. But "pretty unique in history" is going rather too far.
What the west had over the last 100 years is what's pretty unique. It seems to be slipping away, and we should care about that, because it was pretty wonderful.
It was the most violent time we know of. I'd be keen to learn what you refer to as "pretty wonderful".
> But "pretty unique in history" is going rather too far.
I didn't research this properly. But the US army is bigger than the next five biggest armies together. This is an astonishing inbalance. Do you have an example in history where there was a similar inbalance?
It was pretty wonderful in terms of the economic resources available to the median person. That's what you were discussing in the post that I replied to.
> I didn't research this properly. But the US army is bigger than the next five biggest armies together. This is an astonishing inbalance. Do you have an example in history where there was a similar inbalance?
What's with the shift from economic imbalance within a nation to military power between nations? For the discussion we were having, how is the military balance between nations relevant?
To answer your question: Maybe the Pax Romana. Maybe China at certain points.
China is a perfect example as well.
Serbia also comes to mind fairly quickly, and another poster mentioned Vietnam....
North Korea is defacto this as well if you squint past their propaganda even a tiny bit, with the addendum that Kim is the ultimate oligarch.
This is a bit of an oversimplification, don’t you think? Kind of a room temperature take.
You seem to be assuming that it's worse with the existence of countries. I regard that as not proven, and even as unlikely.
But they're still fundamentally capitalist. Their revenue comes from the taxation of capitalist ventures. Very few of the means of production are owned by the people or state. They just do a better job of skimming off that top and putting it to social use. A lot of East Asia is like that too.
The social democracies in Nordic countries are a bit different though, with Norway's state owning or partially owning some of the enterprises that drive their GDP. But there is still private ownership there.
The US by contrast prefers to let the rich keep their money at the expense of everyone else. And they use some of it to buy off the political class, so there's no incentive for the politicians to change the system, especially when both major parties are corrupt and conspire against third parties gaining power.