Based on what that answer is saying, an AI something along the lines of GPT4o - with the ability to lockout YouTube and TikTok and the like - is just going to sky rocket kids learning. Things like Duolingo already are doing the spaced repetition and all that jazz. That stuff is easy enough to handle with software already.
But the accountability portion is key here. We have the hyper addictive apps already now. The kids are successfully hooked. The sugar water is ready for the thirsty rats. Now we just need the supervision, the accountability, the grad student looming above the maze, the gate keeper.
Combining the AIs we already have with the software of spaced repetition and the like should be straightforward. The judgement portion is then essentially solved. All you have to do then is link that output to the ability to access the sugar water, the addictive apps.
The kids are going to do anything to get through these 'lame' educational barriers then.
And all of it will be automated, personalized, and cheap.
Sure, sure, gotta keep an eye on it, spot check things from time to time. Make sure the rascals aren't ginning up the systems and hacking something.
But that is just orders of magnitude cheaper than the near one-on-one instruction that the comment is saying is needed.
> You can actually model this precisely, mathematically, using a forgetting curve. I'm not exaggerating when I refer to these things as laws of physics
That's utter bullshit. There is no precise model for retention time. It isn't mathematics. It isn't even physics. Retention time isn't even the only factor involved.
So what remains of the "mathematically precise forgetting curve"? People forget more and more over time. And even that isn't 100% true.
It's not mathematical in a precision and mechanical sense, but the standard deviation of practical observations from the modeled curve is low enough to make it a good predictor and guide for spaced repetition and to optimize time spent to retention ratio.
The problem with much psychology (and anything ending in -metrics) is that mainstream research in it, for ~century, has been treating the former and latter as equivalent.
There is no property of animals called, "forgetting", and anything we model with stats is, at best, an epiphenomenon. It's important not let the x-metrics disciplines get away with their pseudo-scientific propaganda on this.
Populations of individuals have, on average, rates of memory (etc.) performance across time which can be approximately quantities. It is highly unlikely this corresponds to any physical property.
Temperature isnt, in this sense, an epiphenomnon.
Your description
> aggregate to an apparent quantity that doesnt correspond to anything in the world
is unclear. What do you mean by "the world"?
You go on to say
> There is no property of animals called, "forgetting"
It feels possible to me that a sufficiently complex model of the brain can observe an individual and determine that they are in a state of "forgetting". Not with current technology, of course, but I don't see what rules it out in principle.
Likewise, I don't see why it's impossible for mental states to be reduced (with sufficient computational power) to the states and interactions of the brain's constituent atoms.
Then there are formula on the other end, "teen mazagine regressions", where the terms are superstitious aggregates (eg., star signs, number of times you've kissed, etc.).
And formula/models/etc. inbetween, where terms like 'temperature' correspond to a property that no part has, but there is a "nearly determinsitic" relationship between them, such that necessarily for any given set of measures (x, y,t) you have a temperature.. but that you cannot, in practice, actually set {(x, y, t)} so you have a "stochastic-causal relationship".
My claim is that almost all pscyho-social science is of the teen magazine variety: running linear regressions on surveys and then falsely attributing reality the apparent property given by the correlation coefficient. This is just outright pseudoscience and why much of this stuff is unreporducible nonesense.
There is nothing even like "temperature" to our mental faculties, which if explained with a scientific theory, would comprise a vast number of specific causal properties. To say we "forget something" is to describe a combination of 100s of processes each of which have different ecological expressions.
Likewise, "IQ" is exactly the same sort of psuedoscience: a linear regression through survey responses of an entire population and then a fraudulent pseudoscientific project of taking this correlation coefficient and turning it into a singular mental faculty. 110% BS
Sometimes it's possible to encode the relationships between these properties using mathematical equations that are falsifiable via experiment. But this isn't what makes something physics. Physics is simply the process of applying this approach to matter, energy and force. I mean, I admit that experimental psychology isn't physics. And we don't yet know the mechanisms well enough to have a model that reduces to fundamental interactions. But it's not far off the way that mathematics is (successfully) used to measure and predict phenomena in other scientific fields such as biology.
You're splitting hairs (quite aggressively) over what is essentially semantics. And the worst part is, you're wrong about the semantics.
I'd advise you to remember the adage that, all models are wrong (whether we're talking about physics or psychology). But some models are -useful-.
We only know that population measures correspond to individual properties because of a highly robust independent theory. In general, almost no ensemble statistics of non-trivial non-experimental phemenomna will work this way. This assumption is called, in statistics, the ecological fallacy.
Applying this assumption that a statistics of surface data of complex systems is like physics is pseudoscience. It's funny, indeed, that you use statistics of particles whose behaviour here is absurdly simple. It is this very assumption which is pseudoscience when applied in general.
My semantics are entirely correct.
Just like how individual people have memory, and their ability to recall things can be measured.
> Their having this property follows from QM, it doesnt not follow from population statistics.
Nope. It's entirely impossible to determine the half life of a substance by observing a single particle, nor can the value be derived mathematically from QM or any other theory. The time it will take for a single particle to decay is random and unpredictable, and the half life can only be determined by looking at population statistics.
Even still, the half life is a real physical property, and it does tell us the percent likelihood for a single particle to decay over a given span of time. And if we (for example) wanted to design an experiment or a mechanism, and we were dealing with an unstable substance, we absolutely could use the half life of that substance to decide the optimal parameters of that experiment (e.g. we can use the half life to assume that a certain approximate amount of radiation will be emitted from the substance over a given period of time).
So I really don't see what is so strange or pseudoscientific about saying that, if we know experimentally that people tend to remember things better under certain conditions, then let's apply those conditions in a classroom in an attempt to have the students retain more information. Your argument is basically that particles are simple and people are not. But that's both irrelevant and subjective.
For conditions that don't generalize. If it would be a "mathematical law", spaced repetition would not work, because the retention time would be that of the last presentation. So, we've got some exception. Interference, reinforcement and generalization are another known influences.
Psychology doesn't have a good model of how memory works, whereas there are fairly detailed approximations to model the behavior of e.g. gases. So it isn't mathematics, and it doesn't approach the standards of physics.
And that's also part of what's wrong with cogsci. It has held physics too long as the standard to emulate.
Thankfully, uncertainty is not an obstacle for acquiring useful knowledge. Not in physics, not in cognitive science.
I understand your skepticism, but you're missing out on a LOT of very useful advancements in our understanding of the brain and mind, despite all uncertainty that still remains.