https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispatchable_generation
They are OK as an addition to dispatchable sources, which is why the vast majority of industrialized nations are now planning for a mix of nuclear and intermittent renewables.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispatchable_generation
They are OK as an addition to dispatchable sources, which is why the vast majority of industrialized nations are now planning for a mix of nuclear and intermittent renewables.
A popular political strategy to avoid calling attention to the new thermal power stations is to not call them power stations. They are reserve energy, to be used when intermittent renewables do not produce enough.
The objection to overbuild and storage is economic more than innately about turbines.
Dispatchable and Base load are classic models of nuclear advocacy which are fine, but not unanswerable.
Solar overbuild and batteries alone generally can't handle the burden. You need overbuild and batteries and gas backup. And if you want that gas backup to be hydrogen, you need even more overbuild and electrolysers on top. So quadrupling the very expensive infrastructure that you then have mostly sitting around idle.
You can't get rid of the intermittency problem. You can only move it around, somewhat, at enormous expense.
And the generating capacity required you need is also insane. And that's a quote: "...which challenges the economic sanity of 100% intermittent renewable targets."
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03605...
Your comments about intermittency are demonstrated to be wrong by detailed modeling. Using the tools available (various kinds of storage, transmission, demand dispatch, efficiency) intermittency can be dealt with at an overall cost lower than trying to use nuclear at its current cost.
I believe that link you are pointing to assumes batteries are used for long term storage. This is a common error (if error it is rather than deliberate deception) that inflates the cost of a 100% RE system considerably.
The "insane" comment is just a handwave. The world is going to spend something like a quadrillion dollars on energy this century. Renewables are very likely going to be the least-cost way of powering the world, when the $1000/tonne externalities of CO2 are included.
The situation is similar in most of the developed world.
> Your comments about intermittency are demonstrated to be wrong by detailed modeling
Actually: they are not. All the detailed models show this exact problem, such as the paper I linked.
> The "insane" comment is just a handwave.
No, the "insane" comment is exactly the conclusion of the people who do the detailed modeling.
As this paper (and many others) show, renewables are great as long as they are used for part of energy production. Trying for 100% renewables is the part that's insane.
I recently had a close look at one of the "studies" by Fraunhofer that are frequently touted by renewable advocates as showing how feasible 100% renewables are.
I can't imagine they actually read the study.
For Germany, they say we need 750 GW of Wind/Solar + 500 GWh of batteries + 150 GW of gas plants + the electrolysers to produce the gas. In addition they also assume a massive increase in efficiency and thus reduction in consumption.
Our current electricity generation needs are around 70 GW. OK, some of that is for electrification of other sectors, but for that they also assume massive synergy effects.
This is fantasy-land material that makes the Brexiteer visions of "sunny uplands" appear to be voices of restraint and reason.
That's primary hydro. As I already told you, that's not pumped hydro. You don't seem to be understanding this point, so let me explain in more detail.
Primary hydro involves exploiting natural water flows, extracting energy from water that falls at higher elevations as it flows down to lower elevations. It is limited by these natural water flows, and the need to be on the rivers in which the water is flowing.
Pumped hydro, on the other hand, creates its own water flow. It does not need to exploit natural precipitation. It can recycle the water it uses, getting much more energy flow per unit of water (until the water seeps or evaporates away, but that is slow.) It can be placed in locations that aren't on rivers. As an example, consider this PHES project in an arid part of the Great Basin in Nevada:
https://www.whitepinepumpedstorage.com/
Notice the graphics with two reservoirs, constructed on flat areas by surrounding them with earthen walls, sitting in the middle of a desert without any permanent rivers in sight.
The potential for this sort of pumped hydro is enormous anywhere there is sufficient vertical relief. In Australia, for example, the potential is some 100x what would be needed for a 100% RE grid. They've built a global PHES geographical database for finding places around the world (where they have data; Russia is excluded for example).
http://re100.eng.anu.edu.au/global/
Go play with this; the opportunities are vast.
PHES is not suitable for flat terrain, so it can't be a complete solution in general, but to call it maxed out is very wrong.
> Actually: they are not. All the detailed models show this exact problem, such as the paper I linked.
Let's look at a review paper.
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910
"With every iteration in the research and with every technological breakthrough in these areas, 100% RE systems become increasingly viable. Even former critics must admit that adding e-fuels through PtX makes 100% RE possible at costs similar to fossil fuels. These critics are still questioning whether 100% RE is the cheapest solution but no longer claim it would be unfeasible or prohibitively expensive."
> For Germany, they say we need 750 GW of Wind/Solar + 500 GWh of batteries + 150 GW of gas plants + the electrolysers to produce the gas. In addition they also assume a massive increase in efficiency and thus reduction in consumption.
Battery storage is approaching $100/kWh (not cells, the whole turnkey system) in China now. So, 500 GWh would be $50B. If the batteries have a lifespan of 20 years that's $2.5B/year (+ interest). Can you not afford this? That's less than half of what Germany spends on pizza.
Also, consider how many GWh of storage in cars would be needed if all the cars in Germany were BEVs (I get about 3 TWh).
Yes, you made that claim. However, it's not true. The page is about all hydro in Germany.
https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/themen/klima-energie/erneuerb...
You also need geography for pumped hydro. Somewhere to pump the water to.
> Battery storage is approaching $100/kWh
"Approaching". A Tesla Megapack is more than 3x that.
It's funny how EE fanboys just extrapolate trends into the future. At the rate nuclear power plants were getting cheaper they'd be free now. Well, had we not stopped building them. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Of course, this is very little battery, because that particular Fraunhofer study did most of the backup using gas. With 150 GW of gas fired plants.
150 GW.
Let that sink in. That's more than double the current total demand. Just for backup of the 750 GW of intermittent generators. No wonder that scenario doesn't need all that much battery.
Now add the cost of the electroylysers needed to create all that gas.
> "Approaching". A Tesla Megapack is more than 3x that.
If your argument depends on selecting expensive rather than cheap versions of a technology, I'll do the same with nuclear. Let's use the most disastrous expensive nuclear efforts as representative, shall we?
Or, we could just acknowledge that once a lower price point has been demonstrated for storage, the market will move in that direction. Storage, unlike nuclear, doesn't experience out of the blue cost escalation, and many forms are easily shipped worldwide.
> Of course, this is very little battery, because that particular Fraunhofer study did most of the backup using gas. With 150 GW of gas fired plants.
> That's more than double the current total demand.
The gas generators would not run in baseload mode; they'd be for seasonal and Dunkelflaute coverage. Most energy from the renewables would go either directly to the grid or through batteries and then to the grid. The fraction into gas would be modest.
BTW, simple cycle gas turbine + generator is about 1/20th the capital cost of a nuclear plant per unit power (combined cycle, 1/10th). So 150 GW is not nearly as much as you might imagine.
It doesn't. It depends on available versions of a technology. Not "approaching" versions of a technology.
> Read it again. The limits it discusses are on hydro generation, not hydro storage.
That turns out not to be the case. Try reading it again. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
> The gas generators would not run in baseload mode;
That is EXACTLY the point. You need to overbuild enormous amounts of very expensive infrastructure triply-redundantly and then have it sit around idly most of the time.
So all of this highly expensive triply-redundant and massively overbuilt infrastructure has to be financed by subsidies, as it can't be paid for by producing electricity. As it isn't actually producing any electricity most of the time.
To quote the study again: "...which challenges the economic sanity of 100% intermittent renewable targets."
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03605...
> about 1/20th the capital cost of a nuclear plant per unit power
Yeah, not even close.
Anyway, I think we've reached the limit of what can be accomplished by discussion.
Let's say if we take all the (normal, not "pumped") hydro we have and increase number of turbines on them 10x, or 100x, and make them reversible, that will easily cover all the storage needs in terms of power. Of course, it will not produce more actual electricity than currently because the water in dams in finite, but it will produce almost as much as desired in terms of storage volume. Essentially it's up to "annual hydro output in TWh x 365". In reality, less because hydro output fluctuates in different seasons with the rainfall/river water release, but still... Isn't it way more than we could ever need?
Don't get how pumped hydro can ever be "maxed out".
Playing devil's advocate: once you've run out of places with enough height difference to build one upper and one lower reservoir. It's going to take a long time (there are many more places suitable for pumped hydro than places suitable for traditional hydro), but it's possible.
> Let's say if we take all the (normal, not "pumped") hydro we have and increase number of turbines on them 10x, or 100x, and make them reversible, that will easily cover all the storage needs in terms of power.
That's usually not feasible. Pumped hydro needs both a lower and an upper reservoir, while non-pumped hydro normally has only an upper reservoir, and discharges water directly into a river. That is: even if you made the turbines reversible (or added pumps in parallel with them), there would be no water for them to pump upwards.
For example, Europe is quite far to the north and that means very cloudy winters over most of the continent. If the wind blows, fine, but you can also have several days without wind, when both wind and solar north of the Alps generates basically nothing.
Oh yes, the Spanish meseta will probably still be sunny, but the amount of solar that would be needed to power the rest of Europe for several days probably won't even fit there (not to mention how robust would the pan-European grid have to be to tolerate such flux of energy over thousands of kilometers and ten country borders); and if it does, what will you do with all that extra power in summer?
The fact that real (as opposed to nominal max) output of wind and solar fluctuates in a 1:100 range based on factors that are hard to predict more than a few days in advance is really hard to square with the demand for stable grid. It is a big, fundamental problem.
A simple cycle combustion turbine power plant has a capital cost of maybe 5% of a nuclear power plant; combined cycle, about 10%. So one can substantially back up the entire grid with these at a capital cost low compared to that of powering the grid by nuclear.
That infrastructure is expensive.
And will be sitting idle most of the time.
And, nuclear is not dispatchable either, because it can't be regulated, it's either "on" or "off" (and going from "off" to "on" takes several days due to xenon poisoning).
https://www.energy.gov/articles/cop28-countries-launch-decla...
And you're wrong about nuclear. Brief intro:
Those who plan to use both nuclear and wind/solar don't do it for the dispatchability.
That turns out not to be completely not the case. As in not even close.
First, modern nuclear power plants can do load-following just fine, you often just don't want to because their variable costs are so low that it just makes more sense to keep them running.
Second, the problem with intermittent renewables is that they can't provide power when you need it. Even when you don't load-follow as much, that is not the problem of nuclear.
> As soon as you've ramped up a nuclear reactor to full power, the weather has changed
That's a problem of the intermittent renewables, not of nuclear. You don't make the clown-energy the primary and force everything else to adapt to that.
> Those who plan to use both nuclear and wind/solar don't do it for the dispatchability.
Yeah they do. Dispatchability in terms of grid demand, not in terms of compensating for intermittency.
So, I read a bit and this seems to be actually true, just looking at it from a technical feasibility standpoint [1]. (This is actually the first time someone refuted this point when I made it. ;) )
> Second, the problem with intermittent renewables is that they can't provide power when you need it. Even when you don't load-follow as much, that is not the problem of nuclear.
I didn't say they were, though, and this is not an argument regarding your premise.
> Yeah they do. Dispatchability in terms of grid demand, not in terms of compensating for intermittency.
From a technical standpoint that is true, but, as you've mentioned above: Load-following is not something you can do with nuclear, as the LCOE then quickly meets the other sources of energy ([1], chapter 4).
> That's a problem of the intermittent renewables, not of nuclear. You don't make the clown-energy the primary and force everything else to adapt to that.
Yeah, it's just that that the grid does not end at the gate of the nuclear power plant. Maybe a bit less snark would be helpful in a discussion that can be had based on available data. Referring to solar and wind as clown-energy essentially ends all discussion. Otherwise, people could also bring up arguments such as the limited availability of fuel and the fact that thermal energy generation itself would become a driving factor for global warming if we would still depend on it by the end of the century.
[1] https://www.oecd-nea.org/upload/docs/application/pdf/2021-12...
Yeah, you kind of did:
"Nuclear is almost as non-dispatchable?"
That "almost as" implies not just similarity in degree (which we saw isn't true), but even greater similarity in kind, because otherwise the two are just not comparable in the first place.
"My iPad M4 is almost as fast as a Ferrari" doesn't really make sense, except as humor.
> limited availability of fuel
Not true.
> the fact that thermal energy generation itself would become a driving factor for global warming
Also not true.
Nuclear is only "dispatchable" if you are willing to burn epic, titanic, gargantuan stupid amounts of money.
The only reason to build civilian nuclear power is to aid the provision of skills and an industrial supply chain for the nuclear-military industrial complex. Not the climate. Not cheap, clean power. DEFINITELY not dispatchability.
Nuclear is cheap. According to the Court of Accounts in France in 2012, the whole nuclear industry had cost € 228 billion by that time and produced 11000 TWh of electricity. 2.07 Cents/kWh.
Renewables are expensive, in particular if you want a 100% renewable grid.
There is very little overlap between nuclear and civilian nuclear programs. Lots of countries operate power plants without nuclear weapons, and Israel for example has a military reactor yet does not use nuclear power commercially.
Of course, their plants are aging out in the meaning that those costs are spiking immensely. 2012 is the absolute sweet spot.
The LCOE of nuclear power is ~5x solar and wind.
As a client state of the US, Israel can rely upon and tap the US's nuclear supply chain and skills base.
Its main "not nuclear but not far off it" rival Iran does have nuclear power though, precisely in order to be able to build a nuclear weapon.
Only if you do something insane like the infamous Lazard study that was used to come to this "conclusion": they took a single power plant and used that as "the cost of nuclear".
That alone is enough to disqualify those numbers, but it gets worse. As their one single data point for nuclear, they didn't pick a random sample, but instead they hand-picked the most expensive commercial nuclear power plant in the world: Vogtle-3. That one screwup is their entire dataset for nuclear.
And of course LCOE doesn't actually cover the full cost. When you look at system cost, the renewable get even worse, at least when you try to 100% renewable. As you approach 100% renewables, the costs rise almost asymptotically, "...which challenges the economic sanity of 100% intermittent renewable targets.7".
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03605...
Citation? As far as I know they come out with new numbers every year and they dont just base it on one nuclear power plant.
>And of course LCOE doesn't actually cover the full cost.
It doesnt count the cost of load following, but neither the LCOE for nuclear power. Gas plants are generally used in France to supplement nuclear power when it isn't sufficient to cover their power needs or when they are taken down.
And of course, 5x cheaper = 2-3x cheaper when paired with storage under conservative assumptions.
>As you approach 100% renewables, the costs rise almost asymptotically
If you make some really bad assumptions about how storage will be handled (e.g. assuming you need 2 weeks of lithium ion batteries) sure.
>Citation?
This is v16, April 2023, the most recent I could find,
https://www.lazard.com/media/2ozoovyg/lazards-lcoeplus-april...
Page 5, Footnote (3)
"Given the limited public and/or observable data set available for new-build nuclear projects and the emerging range of new nuclear generation strategies, the LCOE presented herein represents Lazard’s LCOE v15.0 results adjusted for inflation (results are based on then-estimated costs of the Vogtle Plant and are U.S.-focused)"
So v15 is the same. v14 has been withdrawn.
What's really funny is that this footnote has always been there, in plain sight. Yet everyone quotes the Lazard figures as if they were gospel. And if they don't name the source, it's always Lazard anyway.
> [LCOE] doesnt count the cost of load following,
Maybe that as well, but more significantly, it doesn't count system costs, which rise dramatically as more and more of your power generation capacity becomes intermittent.
I don't see exactly where the cutoff is, but most of the industrialized nations seem to betting it's around 80%. The number will obviously vary depending on how willing you are to take on risk. Germany is currently going all-in on that, so I guess the other countries can wait and see how that experiment works out.