* "Psychologists don't want to fix your problems because then you'll stop needing therapy every week."
* "Dating sites don't actually want you to find a long-term partner because then you'll stop using the site."
* "The mechanic's not trying to actually fix your car, just get it running for a few weeks so it breaks down again and you come back."
Etc. etc.
Any time there is information asymmetry and leaving a customer not fully satisfied might lead to future sales, this old canard comes up.
I'm sure in some cases it's true. But, like, people aren't entirely stupid. Consumers generally won't keep repeatedly going back to the same business if the service is kinda sucky. And businesses generally figure out that reputation matters and the most economically viable long-term strategy is just to give people what they want.
This is where the theory falls apart. When “long-term strategy” and “short-term quarterly earnings” get into the boardroom together at a public company, it ain’t “long-term strategy” that’s walking out.
Your examples 1 & 3: I have personally witnessed those negative outcomes.
Regarding 3, A/C repair shops (drain system first, then discuss pricing) and transmission shops (disassemble first, then discuss pricing) are kind of notorious for it.
And yet there are mechanics and therapists who have earned my unquestioning trust.
I've not used 2. I may have bias.
Now think crime and police: without crime, the police would be out of a job.
A consultant has no interest that the project they are consulting on is ever completed.
Of course these examples aren’t to be taken seriously, they merely illustrate some potential conflicts of interest of roles within society.
This isn't a law of nature. It's the result of particular conditions. Businesses in high-trust and low-trust cultures behave differently, and the descent of the US from a high-trust to a low-trust culture is going to have consequences.