I'm sure the motives were good - sometimes it's like finding a needle in a haystack, and it saved lives back then.
But you have mass surveillance, you can go through every hay in the haystack. Yet likely they won't. They'll settle on a middle ground with these outdated methodologies, and combine it with AI/data, to create some form of data-driven astrology. Someone will be inspired by CSI to ask AI to blow up a blurry photo, and AI might just hallucinate it. There will be experts out there who would oppose this, and these could be shut down by their bosses, the politicians who don't understand how it all works.
The Macdonald triad detects the worst criminals, sure, but it mainly detects victims of abuse. Privacy isn't important to the privileged groups; but it's a level of protection for the innocents who could be profiled wrongly.