Recently I had a friend message me to ask me if it was me asking a question at a recorded event with audience questions that they were watching on YouTube (the camera only showed the stage, not audience members at the microphones).
They had absolutely no reason to think I would have been at that particular event.
And I told them, yup -- it was me asking that question a few years ago.
And there is nothing particularly distinctive about my voice. If anything, my voice is probably particularly generic. But it's just timbre, accent, and the unique "fingerprint" of my particular vocal personality.
How many hours has your friend heard you talk? How many hours has the average person heard Scarlett talk? Coupled with the fact that Scarlett is acting when people generally hear her voice, which means some aspects of her vocal qualities change(black widow doesn't sound exactly like her character from Her)
And obviously we're talking about "normal" voices as opposed to impressions or accents. But we still recognize voices even if the voice is doing a wide range of emotions. The same way we don't stop recognizing someone's face when they change from a smile to a frown.
I'm beginning to wonder if you've ever considered your interactions with other people, or if you're just making this up as you go along.
We certainly have memory, and can forget people, like a random person we were once shown a picture of. And pictures are not 3D faces either.
But if you meet someone for half an hour and then run into them later that day, you recognize them just as easily as you do your mother. There's zero doubt that they are the person you met earlier (unless you have face blindness or something). You don't have to meet them for 10 more hours to be able to recognize them instantly.
Sure you might forget them a year later but that has nothing to do with your recognition capabilities, but with memory.
Which, given the fact that the voice actor for Sky has put out a statement stating that her voice has never been compared to Scarlett's in real life, makes me think that people are just hallucinating that Sky sounds like Scarlett. For what it is worth, I listened to them side by side(before OpenAI put out a statement by the voice actor) and they are not the same voice.