Who is to say Christians didn’t use their discernment to conclude that Jesus is who he claimed and did what was said of him?
Anyone paying even casual attention to the epistemology of Christians.
I'll certainly admit lots of Christians have bad epistemology, because frankly lots of people do in general. But there are also lots of people who have thought about this very seriously, contrary to your claim.
I'm sure there are. But if they ended up confirming belief in a magic carpenter born of a virgin, then we're back to bad epistemology.
Not all contexts are equally valid or equally believable. Some of them disqualify themselves pretty quickly.