Private shops largely have a right to bar whoever they want from being a customer, except in protected categories ("shoplifter" isn't one of those). The problems here are (a) no one understands type I / type II errors, (b) everyone trusts computers must be right all the time, and (c) there's no easy way for this particular customer to prove that she's not the shoplifter. (c) could be fixed by a process. (a) and (b) are very hard nuts to tackle.