2. Taxes are a means to an end, as is the government. There's no benefit to fining people for clerical mistakes besides encouraging them to not make them. There's no value created by fines. There's no shareholder greedily pocketing the revenue. If they can avoid mistakes for people, that benefits government employees by having to waste less time on stupid stuff, the taxpayers by not having to waste time on stupid stuff and avoiding fines, and the people at large by not having to waste public money on paying people to fix stupid stuff on people's returns.
2. In an ideal world, yes. In practice, citation needed.
EITC makes up 36% of all audits and its for people making below 20k.
https://www.propublica.org/article/earned-income-tax-credit-...
You only get fined if you deliberately (and fraudulently) fuck up.
If you make a mistake, they give you a chance to correct it before fining you.
I forgot a W-2 once (I switched jobs 4 weeks into the year and the first employer gave me my W-2 late) and filed without it. My return was rejected and I got a letter telling me why and requested an amended return. I amended, re-filed, got accepted, and got my refund. No fines.
And certainly no jail time like a lot of memes like to suggest.
Tax policy is the government's strongest tool to change personal behavior, and if the system is simple and automated it doesn't do that at all.
If anything it’s a great opportunity to put personalized suggestions for how to reduce one’s taxes (=change behavior) directly in front of the eyeballs you want to see it. Put it directly on the page where you click “looks good to me” on the automatically-filled-in tax form.
“Looks like you’ve never used your one-off solar panel federal tax credit. Click here for information on how to save up to $xx,xxx on next year’s taxes, while also reducing your energy bill!”
I'm not sure I agree. For example, I used to pay city wage tax to one municipality, and I decided I did not want to pay that city tax anymore so I took a job in another area that no longer had the city wage tax. I would be due the wage tax no matter what, and I was aware of exactly how much the wage tax was by looking at my pay stub every two weeks. Having my taxes prepared for me doesn't really change that.
It is possible to do the same societal effect in other ways, but the US does a done at the federal level via taxes.
Go look sometimes at the list of things you can claim in various cases.
It's even more explicit when you look at business tax returns and schedules.