I've always thought that these "recommendations" were just the best guesses at the time. I didn't think they were "scientific". I thought it was obvious to everyone.
Who is going to volunteer to stand 1,2,3,4,5,6 ft away and test whether covid infection happens in March 2020?
What scientific evidence could we have come up with in such a short notice?
Protecting against aerosolized virus communication is and was, quite well studied. Covid did not change physics.
Why trust them now? This is the third reversal, just on the mask issue. Was burning all that credibility really worth it?