The primary takeaway from this transcript is that republicans decided to waste another 14 hours of Fauci’s time.
The primary takeaway from this transcript is that republicans decided to waste another 14 hours of Fauci’s time.
That's quite the historical revisionism.
Between flip-flopping reccomendations, ineffective mandates, and functionally shutting the whole country down, I find it hard to believe someone believes the measures taken during the pandemic were "minimally invasive" or "common sense".
At times, public discourse felt more like some war between political factions than a country dealing with an inconvenient highly-infectious virus.
I will never forget the cult-like fanatacism surrounding the virus and vaccines from my peers during that time (went to an extremely liberal high school). Its even more insane how quickly those people just stopped caring entirely after lockdown ended and the news cycle moved onto the next Biggest Thing Ever, of the week.
I of course would not have said that we could have reduced covid infections by following the steps you suggest. But governmental mandates need to take into account both sides of the ledger. If having kids in school could have prevented massive learning loss and not resulted in significant additional deaths/hospitalizations, then that's something worth considering.
What do you and Jim expect to learn from a scientific study? That 12 feet is better than 6 feet?
I’d like to hear from each of you what you hope to learn, and why you think it would have been worth intentionally infecting people with covid-19, as that’s what would be required for a conclusive scientific study.
I don't know anyone named Jim, nor am I saying we need to have definitive studies before giving out guidance. However, if we are going to give out guidance that ends up requiring schools to space out kids' desks in a way that makes it impossible for many of them to open, I think that guidance should either be grounded in science or admitted to be a best-guess. This is about transparency and honest, which are especially important when the government issues mandatory rules that upend life as we know it.
The best evidence of this is still the nearly controlled experiment that happened on the Diamond Princess cruise ship early on, which was completely ignored afterwards due to what it showed.
Hundreds of thousands of people spent days in our hospitals. If PPE was not effective, every doctor and nurse in the country would have been sick by week 2.
Masks had no effect. This isn't a lie. Look at any graph of cases from any country you care to pick, then try and draw a line where mask mandates were added or removed. You won't be able to, because even when a whole population was forced to start wearing a mask overnight there was no inflection in the graphs. The point of everyone wearing masks was to slow down the growth in those graphs, or even put it into reverse. Yet nothing happened. This is absolute proof that they did not work.
That's why the argument for masks always ends up relying on invalid lab studies using mannequins, or self-reinforcing models that just prove their own assumptions, or arguments of the form "people just didn't wear the right kind of masks". When you look at what was actually tried, the ground truth data doesn't show any effect.
Regarding doctors and nurses, they are trained in how to wear PPE and are much more likely to do so appropriately than civilians or (especially) children. PPE can be effective against COVID, but probably 1-5% of civilians wore masks according to protocols. Wearing a mask incorrectly might help, but AFAIK there are zero studies on this.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9123350/
These findings indicate that countries with high levels of mask compliance did not perform better than those with low mask usage.
There are literally no correlations anywhere to be found. No impact on case numbers (the goal!) and no link between compliance and outcomes. That's because masks cannot stop an aerosolized gas from entering the body, it just goes through or around them. Aerosolized agents can also enter you via the eyeballs, which is why real gas masks also protect the eyes:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9631193/
Especially easy for SARS-2 because the cornea has the ACE2 receptors the virus uses to enter cells:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7293510/
This sort of thing is why masks have no effect and at first health officials said that. They were right. But governments wanted to do something, and that was something, so public health "scientists" swiftly fell into line and overnight "the science" was suddenly saying the opposite.