Like you ask it to do one thing it's amazing, but then you try to modify or do something with extra steps, or just anything with any complexity to it and it falls over.
Like you ask it to do one thing it's amazing, but then you try to modify or do something with extra steps, or just anything with any complexity to it and it falls over.
I would like to believe that but I have had too many conversations with people who basically think it already is. Including in one situation of a fellow engineer.
It feels like more and more "we" are in a bubble of actually having some knowledge of how this works, what the actual limitations are, and what it just is not. While there is in fact criticism of it out there, particularly around AI "art". It doesn't seem to be focused on the area we are talking about.
They are being sold as such. Most people don't know anything about the topic and will buy that marketing. The entire concept of these models is that you can put a whole bunch of data in and eventually some kind of magic will happen and you get AGI out. They would not see the kind of investment that they do if all that was being promised was "really good predictive text". In fact some philosophers argue that sentience is just really good predictive text to try and make the point that these models are AGI.
it's true that they're not very reliable, but they seem to be not very reliable across many different domains. and they don't seem to be particularly less reliable than the average human, so i think possibly your standards for 'general purpose ai' are set high enough that you would declare humans to be unintelligent (or perhaps not 'general-purpose') if you applied them consistently
you can certainly find particular domains where humans can still do things llms can't, but i haven't seen a persuasive account of why those domains are the more important ones, and of course the converse is also true
https://www.noemamag.com/artificial-general-intelligence-is-...
Then you have the people who are leveraging the technology to train models from scratch and that population is far more apt to believe that large models can be general purpose AI (by some definition). Sure there are other things at play like money, publicity, reputation, and a desire to do something important. But there is also the very clear trend line where transformers are able to model pretty much any sequence of tokens where there is pretraining scale data available. Whisper was not a surprise. GPT-4v was not a surprise. Sora was not a surprise.