More data is needed before thinking you can determine the formula.
More importantly, it is trivial to understand the reasoning behind assuming a higher probability of someone repaying debt if they have a history of successfully repaying debts.
The same as anything else in life.
There are a lot of very specific assumptions in there about the mechanism.
How do you know which dates' balances are relevant to the calculation? If your credit score is 800, then you probably don't have a "credit utilization" of zero, as it's widely believed that the optimal % is more than zero (not "too low" but also not "too high", whatever that means).
They also won't knock you if you are a few days late. I have been late a handful of times before and never took a hit. They will also reimburse the late fee if you call, but obviously they won't do this often.
The optimal ratio is very close to 0[1]:
+-----------------------+---------------------+
| Range | Average Utilization |
+-----------------------+---------------------+
| 300-579 (Poor) | 82.1% |
| 580-669 (Fair) | 56.1% |
| 670-739 (Good) | 35.2% |
| 740-799 (Very good) | 14.7% |
| 800-850 (Exceptional) | 6.5% |
+-----------------------+---------------------+
Basically the concept is that if you're already borrowing as much money as people are willing to lend you, those people probably have a good reason to not want to lend you more.Also, as a bonus, the utilization component doesn't have history. If you're about to take out a loan, you can just borrow/pay back as much debt as you want the previous month for an ideal utilization.
[1]: https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/credit-education...
> Now things get a little trickier. Paying your balances in full each month isn't the same as maintaining 0% utilization. Here's why.
> Credit scoring systems calculate utilization using balance information that card issuers report monthly to the national credit bureaus (Experian, TransUnion and Equifax). Each issuer reports balance information on its own schedule, and many report to different bureaus on different days of the month. Each credit bureau also has its own timetable for revising your credit report once it has received a card issuer's update.
> For these reasons, if you use your credit cards at all, your utilization can vary from day to day at any one credit bureau—and it will differ from one credit bureau to another, even though all of their records are accurate.
> Here's a simple example:
> Let's say you use a credit card with a $5,000 credit limit and zero balance to make a $500 purchase on the 10th of the month. You then pay that balance in full on the 20th, before the charge even appears on your statement. If the card issuer reports your balance information to Experian on the 15th, then credit scores based on Experian data will reflect 10% utilization for that card on that month. Meanwhile, another credit bureau that gets updated on, say, the 25th will reflect 0% utilization for that card.
> Factor in multiple cards and balances, and you can see that your utilization on any given day is something of a moving target, and so are credit scores based on it. (The normal differences between credit scores based on data at different credit bureaus is one reason many lenders use more than one credit score when processing loan or credit applications.)
> Put another way, the only way to be sure you have 0% utilization all the time is to refrain from using your credit cards at all...
If you're trying to say that you should avoid credit altogether, that's a terrible idea... Unless you plan on not getting a mortgage and paying for your home in cash. In which case your personal financial situation might not be representative of the average / median Joe.
If you build a robust budget and spend within that, you will have an 800 score. Do that. Do it intentionally.
Credit agencies evaluate risk, so even if you can stomach that $1200/mo car payment on your $50k/yr job. You are gonna take a hit for making a stupid financial decision, because even if you make those payments, you are almost certainly teetering on the edge to do it. (never mind that your score was probably already bad given the thought process to take on that loan).
Banks don't want to loan to people who are lucky and always somehow pull it out. They want to loan to people who are smart and reliable. Credit agencies try to filter for that.
I don't think that's how credit scores work, at all.
Also, it's not actually true that everyone uses credit scores. More recently companies use custom risk models because they see this as a competitive advantage. (Especially the afterpay companies like Klarna don't use them.)
Please show me the calculation methodology of any major credit scoring agency.
Rough guidelines aren't cutting it.
So, F this line. It's only true if it also includes "...and intentionally aquire and actually use a couple of credit cards that you don't want and don't need, for no other reason than to go through the motions." And even then it still doesn't result in an exactly great credit score if you always pay in full and never carry a balance. Even after years. 10 so far for me since the above. It's ok, but not great.
So yeah, F this line.
Paying off cards in full each month is the absolute best thing to do for your credit score (and saving money by not paying interest).
I think it would depend on your credit utilization %. If your credit utilization is too low, it may hurt your score. Of course if your credit utilization % is too high then it's an (even worse) issue. But who really knows? It's not like we have the formula.
Of course, who really knows? And the fact that we can't really know is the real problem IMO.
On the other side, you get benefits and money back for using your credit card. So people are in a situation where they really should use a card for everything. It also makes it easier to get good credit as long as your treat it like cash.