dark mode cultists are truly a strange breed. personally i like neither dark nor light mode, but more of a sepia tone at a lower brightness that I feel is much more soft on my eyes.
both dark and light mode feel way too harsh, both in terms of contrast and the usual color pallettes people often choose (bright whites [ #eee and above] and dark blacks [ #111 and below] )
Lack of automatic dark mode support on websites is very annoying at night, when you've turned dark mode on and everything else is dark, except that one website you just opened, and it now hurts your eyes or bothers other people in the bedroom.
I never use dark mode on a laptop (because I hate it, it's a personal preference), not even at night. I don't bring a laptop to the bedroom if anyone else is there.
That's why automatic dark mode on websites doesn't have any effect unless you turn on dark mode. It lets you choose.
We need to put the UA back into UA and let people decide how they want sites to look.