Psychology might be a big stinkin' load of hogwash and that's just fine
experimental-history.com
experimental-history.com
That’s not the advertisement for psychology you think it is..
During my studies psychology we replicated some alleged results as well. We were students, so I’m sure we didn’t do all of it properly, but we actually usually found the opposite results.
And you (probably) have no idea how bad the statistics in quite some psychology studies are, especially in this field they very often assume basic normal distributions without any testing, and stare blindly at a p-value of .05 regardless of the study.
Of course there are also a lot of very ingenious and good studies, but from my personal experience (for whatever that’s worth), psychology as a field has some serious catching up to do to more STEM based fields.
All of this being merry my own experience of course, I readily admit I have not done the science in this regard.
Is it really possible? And if it was, think about the implications for social control and democracy, etc. Might this actually be more dangerous than anything to do with LLMs.
Or is it like the search for the philosophers stone that transmuted base metals to gold?
Also, how many people will get hurt and messed up in the process?
Try and find an exception to this simple rule.
That aside, huge fan of his comedy!
[1] That's just one of them, I see him on TikTok quite a bit shooting his mouth off.
I'm also critical of the post's author when they say "Try to explore her jungles and she will send snakes and mosquitoes to stop you." . 'Nature' as a personification is a metaphor, and animals are not collectively trying to stop you from scientific enquiry. Nor is knowledge being kept secret from you. My view is that all organisms are simply trying to make a living for themselves and why would you imagine phenomena are arranged for easy discovery or otherwise?
My advice is to avoid getting lost in your own analogies. That's the path to the insane asylum. Physician heal thyself!
Well, then perhaps your field doesn't matter in aggregate?
He has this premise that "the field is disparate findings anyway" so even if most are shot down, doesn't matter, but even in that case, seems like a waste and very low signal vs noise ratio to keep it up...
To me personally this philosophy makes for a richer and more rewarding inner world.
Computational irreducibility does away with any practical significance the simulation hypothesis could have, and it provides structure to plans-turned-paths-to-the-future. Your attention into the future is one degree of irreducibility, your consciousness is another, and the zeitgeist of our age is a third, resulting in an ego with three shells.