And then iPhone came along and Apple said "Trust us, our store review policy will save you.". And Android did the same. And Zuck said "Your data is safe, a Facebok app can't steal your data, because it'll get into trouble with us!". And then Cambridge Analytica data-mined FB users and used targetted ads on the gullible to deliver the election to Trump...
The other part of the problem is that the apps receive an exception or equivalent at all. IMO, they should receive fake access that returns either no items or garbage data as applicable.
Prompt the user "App Foo wants to use calendar/pictures/location" and then you have options like "Allow", "Deny", "Allow with filtered data" (i. e. select just a few photos out of the gallery), or "Allow with bogus data" (generated gibberish that goes away after use)