Do I have a wholly-incorrect understanding of epigenetics? Is there a clear and simple example of an epigenetic mechanism?
Do I have a wholly-incorrect understanding of epigenetics? Is there a clear and simple example of an epigenetic mechanism?
Inherited trauma is totally unsupported but up or down regulated gene expression based on environmental factors before your conception are supported by some compelling evidence.
Your genes are a recipe book, not a blueprint. What recipe is chosen is based somewhat on environmental effects. When you reproduce, you shuffle together the parents book + the earmarks on the pages.
This is only true if you take a pretty narrow definition of the word "trauma".
One example would be an ancestor experiencing famine, who then passes down epigenetic markers have marked effects on their offspring in terms of health, longevity, and behavior.
Here's a Nature article on it: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41418-023-01159-4
> "Collectively, these discoveries infer the existence of “a heritable memory of starvation/hunger”."
Also the phrase "a heritable memory" is kind of nonsense even with respect to epigenetic changes. Again what we're talking about with epigenetics is up or down regulation of your existing genes, not some new information being encoded.
I fully agree that someone starving to death right around the time of pregnancy could have some knock on effects; this is discussing changes in the following generation, the ones that are tens of years removed from the starvation event.
> Also the phrase "a heritable memory" is kind of nonsense even with respect to epigenetic changes. Again what we're talking about with epigenetics is up or down regulation of your existing genes, not some new information being encoded.
I wonder if you are missing the forest for the trees here somewhat. We're talking about the up/down regulation of specific genes based on specific methylation patterns in DNA that are present only because of some event that occurred. It's not memory in the sense of "I remember what I had for breakfast this morning", but it's memory in the sense of "these methylation patterns exist because their genesis was triggered by a specific event in the last few generations". That IS new information being encoded, just in a more fuzzy way than with neurons or computer memory.
I would need more convincing to think the phrases you mention are nonsense/bunk. Could you perhaps articulate the definitions you're using for "trauma" and "memory"? I think we are using different definitions, as it seems clear what is meant by the phrases as used.
EDIT: what issue do you take with the Dutch hunger study? I hadn't heard criticism about it before, and I just googled "dutch hunger cohort study criticism" and found nothing.
x2
@ch4s3 is making some pretty strong claims here and there, for which I do not see the evidence either.
Don't take me wrong, I don't mean to suggest he's just being a quack; but rather, this is an invitation for him to substantiate his knowledge. The more we learn the better, :).
My criticism is that a lot of studies based on the data to lazy things like this, draw big conclusions, and get a lot of citations but there just isn’t much to them.
[1] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C39&q=%E2...
Wooos, posted the wrong link earlier. https://obgyn.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1471-0...
I really don't have the time or energy to go through all of them, tbh.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I think "in the last few generations" is a little speculative. There's strong evidence for epigenetic changes being passed from parents, but going further back the evidence is much weaker.
> what issue do you take with the Dutch hunger study
It's a really narrow study of a rather genetically homogeneous group picked from a really small geographic area and it has all of the issues of any retrospective study. The outcome could just be random chance. If you look at any small closely related group you're just going to find some sort of weird clustering, even if it varies in that group. If similar epigenetic markers showed up in other populations with similar well documented circumstances it would be stronger.
The classic example of epigenetics - of stable information transfer between cell generations not based on DNA sequence - is methylation of cytosines. Here's the simplified version. As you know, the DNA is based on ACTG. When you have a CG, the C can be methylated, which means an extra carbon is attached at a specific position on the molecule. That extra carbon gets 'copied' when the DNA is duplicated during mitosis and gets passed to the daughter cells. Yet it can be added or erased during the cell's lifetime. It typically works to block proteins responsible for transcribing genes into mRNA from binding to the gene, so the gene is silenced when it is methylated. This gives a way to transmit patterns of gene expression across generations of cells.
This mark is extremely well-studied and understanding everything about DNA methylation is beyond this humble PhD student. But there are also extremely mechanisms for erasing and/or resetting certain aspects of cell state during mitosis or meiosis, including RNA, the proteome, and methylation state. We can't take it for granted that just because there's a mechanism by which biochemical information could be transmitted that it actually is (or that it isn't).
A common source for the idea of intergenerational trauma being supported by epigenetic evidence is the Dutch hunger winter [1]. The idea is that an experience that parents had in utero seems to have had an effect on the physical development of their children, in a way that's specific to parental sex. I'm willing to say "sure, that effect could be real and there could be an epigenetic explanation." But AFAIK we don't know specifically what that hypothetical mechanism would have been.
Note that the bod(y|ies) of the mother and child are interchanging material and engaging in biochemical crosstalk constantly during gestation, so there is abundant opportunity for environmental influences on the mother to have lifelong impacts on the child. Since the child's body will in turn engage in the same 'dialog' with the child's own children during fertilization and gestation, it's entirely possible for environmental influences on generation 1 to impact generation 3 as mediated by generation 2 via an in utero exposure.
All that said, I have a lot of uncertainty about what our priors ought to be on how important such hypothetical mechanisms might be. I think that in the coming decades, we'll make huge progress in understanding development and disease within an individual's body through an epigenetic lens. We will probably also see some interesting controlled experiments on "epigenetic inheritance" using short-lived model organisms, such as fruit flies or worms. Possibly we will collect enough epigenetic information in large-scale biobanks over 20-40 years that we can get a more detailed understanding of possible epigenetic inheritance mechanisms in humans, but these assays are currently quite expensive, and moreover there's no single measure applicable to an individual person, since the whole point of epigenetics is that the state varies across cell and tissue type.
[1] https://www.ohsu.edu/school-of-medicine/moore-institute/dutc...