In this case, as is typical with such things, the study itself is fine but the news headline implies a finding that categorically cannot be claimed or supported by this type of study, and is not in the study itself.
In this case, as is typical with such things, the study itself is fine but the news headline implies a finding that categorically cannot be claimed or supported by this type of study, and is not in the study itself.
This is like arguing about chiropractic or homeopathy papers. The field is diseased and you are wasting your time if you read or analyze individual papers.
This particular study is an observational study. That is only the very first part of trying to understand things- they notice some correlations, which can be further studied later on. They don't typically tell you anything concrete or actionable as they cannot establish cause and effect. That doesn't mean there is anything fraudulent or "junk" about them- typically the authors will be honest about the limitations in the paper, but the pop news articles like the one linked here may not be.
There are established correlations between gut biome and mental health. But correlation is not causation.