Maybe not in the US, but in the EU that's possible. Maybe all that outright opposition to regulation isn't necessarily a good thing...?
they've discovered that their ToS is something they can abuse and write whatever they wish and pretend it's law. And because consumers both dont read it, and don't understand it, it becomes difficult for the consumer to disambiguate what is legal and what isn't.
https://www.termsfeed.com/blog/return-refund-laws-eu/#:~:tex...
That said, one of the many many problems of the "free market" is that it depends on there being a company willing to leave huge stacks of money and power on the table.
Maybe some company could take a few customers from their competitors by offering great refunds and fair terms when no one else will, but why would they ever do that when they'll make far more money if they screw over their customers just like everyone else is doing? Sometimes, it will always be more profitable for companies to refuse to give consumers what they want, at which point it becomes impossible to vote with your wallet since there is no one to give your money to except those who are doing what you'd prefer to "vote" against.
Especially when companies are either colluding directly with each other or just looking for the company with the most oppressive and abusive polices/practices and copying what they do, your options drop off very very quickly. Even if you do manage to find a company that seems like it's good, it's just a matter of time until enshittification kicks in and the service degrades because ultimately, companies are all looking out for themselves and insist on endless growth and higher and higher profits so they all push to charge you as much as they possibly can while delivering as little as possible in return. It's a race to the bottom where you always lose.
i pick option three: the current system.
Also, why don't you read that you are answering to: "The fact that you can't even get refunds (e.g. within 15 days or something) for most software is ridiculous", dear Civilized World? : )
You never read what you are answering too, like "The fact that you can't even get refunds" or "how do you return if you don't buy"? :D
Fraudsters don't get rich. And more importantly, wannabe fraudsters have their dream career path cut off. It's a huge downside to them all.
Your risk management is entirely your own concern. I would never want a paternalistic government dictating when and how I interact with the market. Why do you want to impose it on me?
> The (quite small) risk of falling through the cracks and ending up hard stuck is just something one risk-accepts when signing up to a service and maintaining important data there.
Why should it be? Fuck that!
> I would never want a paternalistic government dictating when and how I interact with the market. Why do you want to impose it on me?
The government wouldn't dictate your actions at all here.
It's just part of doing business. Know who you're transacting with, pay attention to the specifics of your agreement, and do your due diligence. This is very basic stuff. If you have a dispute, then it gets resolved in court. That's literally what courts are for. If our courts can't keep with demand, we should fix that problem.
> The government wouldn't dictate your actions at all here.
They are, they're saying that the companies I transact with must have customer service/refund/consumer protection level above x. I'd like to choose my own risk level when transacting with others. If I want a (presumably cheaper) deal with a fly-by-night, high-risk, vendor why should anyone else have the right to stop me? It's my risk to take.
It's the same argument as with credit. If I want to borrow money at an "usurious" rate (presumably because no one else will lend to me), why should anyone else stop me? It's my risk to take and my bankruptcy on the line.
Most industries don't have the pattern of blocking people on a whim. It should not be a part of doing business just because big tech companies find it easier. And due diligence doesn't work for proprietary social media. There are no proper alternatives because they don't interoperate.
To put that first point another way, lack of capricious banning and similar has been a business norm until now and hasn't been a legal issue, but if companies with millions of customers are going to cause problems then we should collectively bargain their ability to access those millions of customers against those basic standards.
> That's literally what courts are for. If our courts can't keep with demand, we should fix that problem.
There is a huge amount of friction to go to court. I sure don't want every business in the world to be encouraged to ride the edge of "barely not worth suing".
Solving that friction is not feasible.
> It's my risk to take.
It's hard to measure that risk, and if everyone has to spend lots of time taking care of due diligence for every purchase then that's pure waste that hurts everyone. Purely free markets depend on everyone having sufficient information and that doesn't fit the real world.
And if the fly by night vendor makes a lot of sales by being 1% cheaper, from people that didn't intentionally accept the risk, they take market share and it's harder to find a competent vendor.
That said, I'm also suspicious of public employee unions. Unions, in general, are a necessary counterweight to capital - but that incentive structure doesn't exist within the public sector. The best argument one might advance is that a public-employee union can resist sabotage (as above) of their department's work, but that's poor governmental practice (I would, quite frankly, prefer that those impairing administrative function have the consequences of their actions quickly discovered), and not what usually seems to happen in the real world.