Section 230 Sunset Act Would Cut Off Young People's Access to Online Communities
teenvogue.com
teenvogue.com
230 is what prevents websites from having the legal obligation to identity users.
with 230, any crime in user content, they can just tell the govt that they will take content down and gov can go and hunt the criminals.
without 230, they have to provide an alibi to what now is their crime. so no operator will ever allow you to post a word without providing a photo id and credit card payment as proof.
and this what they want so the digital id, which will be totally optional, Will end up being required everywhere because it would be the easier way to implemented the "way out".
This is completely untrue. Section 230 does not protect from criminal liability. It protects from civil liability.
This why hosting criminal material, such as CSAM, is not protected.
It is an immense difference though. Civil and criminal law differ in almost every single conceivable way.
You literally go on to name one very important difference. The threshold for civil litigation is someone deciding to file a pro se suit against you by giving something vaguely resembling a legal document to a court. The chilling effect of that is much more dramatic than criminal liability.
Plus, there's the worker protections angle, many people depend on these platforms for their livelihood, and the platforms get the benefit of their content in exchange, yet the platform can massively harm their livelihood and the victim typically can't do much in return. In contrast, even gig workers with Uber etc get some basic legal protections.
To pick a benign, non-polarizing example, YouTube is constantly banning or demonetizing people who have not broken their stated policies, be it a history channel or a completely sfw drawing tip channel.
Another example of the power imbalance would be how Reddit can delete anything they want in the name of moderation, but when the users revolt and start to take away their content, Reddit can just undelete it.
By talking of repealing 230, they're in-effect throwing out the baby with the bathwater, but it was supposed to be our representatives' job to understand the people's underlying concerns and draft appropriate legislation.
Not a lawyer but I'm pretty sure if you undelete it without the user's permission then it's just _your_ content then and no longer liable for 230 protection.
Think a lot of younger people feel that the government is treating them like infants with their recent forays into social media regulation. I’m surprised the Republicans don’t view this as a chance to pick up votes.
55% of younger people voted in 2020 compared to 66% turnout overall. it seems incredibly foolish to ignore that demo just because they have 10% points lower turnout
combine this ban with Trump's recent stance on tipped wages & Biden's polling and it is looking awful for Ds among precisely the demos they need to get to turnout
For citizens ages 18-34, 57% voted in 2020
In the 35-64 age group, turnout was 69%
In the 65 and older group, 74% voted in 2020
Only 50% of citizens 18-29 voted. And some people count the youth vote as 18-24.Meanwhile 39% in a presidential election year is a more typical number.
Also, given that both parties voted for the TikTok ban, who are all these people going to vote for?