Making price changes easier for workers is cool, but can we not have surge pricing for some things? This is getting ridiculous.
Making price changes easier for workers is cool, but can we not have surge pricing for some things? This is getting ridiculous.
Is that really the case? Gas prices change daily and are closely correlated with crude oil prices.
I think you missed the first part of the comment where they addressed that:
>Commodity markets are essentially auctions. That's a completely different thing.
Absolutely. If everyone raised their prices of umbrellas due to rain, I'd lower my prices a bit to get those customers. I'd probably wind up making more overall too. Hopefully it will also lead to increasing return customers due to goodwill. If everything works out, not only would I sell more umbrellas, but I'd make more money in the future from returning customers. Win for me. And I feel like that's why we _don't_ have surge pricing on everything already.
And then so would they, and so would you, and so would they, and pretty soon you'll all find an equilibrium-while-raining price.
Assuming they don't all crash and get replaced with paper
A lot of stores increase their prices when they're expecting something like bad/good weather, events, etc., and it's fine for me. But when prices are increased momentarily due to a sudden need, that just feels bad for the customers. And it's not just me. A lot of people feel that way. That's why there's such a negative connotation to surge pricing.
As a small scenario, if I came to your booth when it isn't raining and asked about umbrella prices and you quoted a price, would you respect that price if I came back later if it started raining? If yes, then great. If not, and you raise the price, do you think that I won't say negative things about your booth to others? You may gain a few dollars in the short term, but overall you may lose more than the few dollars you gained.
And a reason I said I'd have to think about it: A solo person selling to a small flea market affects a lot less people than a major grocery chain. Like even if you did raise the price to me when it started raining, I wouldn't feel bad, knowing that you're just a small seller. When a large multi-billion dollar revenue chain does it, it feels bad, since they're just taking advantage and don't give a damn.
Side note: I stopped using Uber during surge pricing due to the fact the driver doesn't actually get a good portion of it. If the driver got all or most of the extra pricing because they're the one's stuck in traffic, I probably wouldn't mind.
If 100 people come into your store to buy the 50 umbrellas you carry, isn't it better for everyone to raise the prices? Some of those 100 might not REALLY need an umbrella, and are just buying it because they think they should (or to resell later!). If you raise the prices, you drive those buyers away and leave more product for the people who need it the most.
Walmart is huge and probably has, in some areas, some kind of monopoly. If you sell your stuff on a flea market, I can deal with you to get a price that suits both of us. You have competition all around you, easy to reach, easy to compare. You are selling umbrellas, Walmart is selling water, one of if not the most basic food, for a maximum profit.
The additional profit goes straight into your pocket. Same for Walmart, it's not like the employees somehow benefit from a price raise.
Yes, the free market works like that: demand and offer control the price. But at some point this reaches the area of immorality.
How will you feel when customers do the same, and try to get as much as they can for as little as possible? It’s free to buy an umbrella and then return it when it stops raining. Is that less ethical than surge pricing? It’s based on the same premise; their need for an umbrella now makes the umbrella worthless so they regret the decision.
It erodes trust in the market. It shows consumers that businesses are willing to capitalize on their inelastic demands, which encourages responses in kind. I would wager consumers find it less unethical to abuse returns or steal from price gouging vendors.
On a long enough timeline as a common enough practice, I think we all lose. Those frustrations become crippling market inefficiencies and both customers and producers are worse off.
That's easily solvable with a clause in the return policy like "no returns if the product is used". AFAIK electronics retailers have added similar clauses because people were buying TVs for the superbowl and then returning them afterwards. More likely though, a place that sells umbrellas, especially in tourist areas would have a "no refund" policy.
The specific actions aren’t really the point, the point is that it rapidly becomes an antagonistic relationship, which is bad for the market in aggregate.
aka. "we do a little wire fraud"
More seriously, if the merchant has a clearly documented "no refunds" policy they'll probably prevail in chargeback. Also, if you're the type of person who's going to chargeback a $10 umbrella, you're probably not going to have a credit card to do chargebacks with for long.
>The specific actions aren’t really the point, the point is that it rapidly becomes an antagonistic relationship, which is bad for the market in aggregate.
Having a "no refunds" policy is an "antagonistic relationship" now?
Airlines/hotels/rental cars/theme parks charge more for days where demand is anticipated to be higher. Any expiring good works this way.
Sample size of 1 but my local flea market does not. The fee is the fee, rain or shine.
Isn't surge pricing how you prevent shortages? If you are going to the store for milk, would you rather have a 50% chance to be able to buy it at $3, or a 100% chance to buy it at a variable price between $2 and $4?
The only difference is that companies make more money from selling the same products, and that products in short supply are distributed more towards the people with deeper pockets.
Right, but arguably with surge pricing it can put the limited supply into people who need it the most. Without price gouging laws/price controls, no matter how badly/ambivalent about buying the milk, you'll buy it. Upping the price forces everyone to weigh how badly they need the milk, and ensures that people who need it the most gets it. Of course, the usual caveat of "willingness/ability to pay =/= neediness" applies, but price is probably the best mechanism we have short of setting up a Bureau of Rationing and having everyone fill out a 10 page application justifying why they need milk.
I'm sure that will all trickle down.