Atlanta has been using a form of these contactless paper tickets since 2006.
Romans have used tickets before AD, guy at the gate checked it without any contact
Thunder Bay, Ontario. Pop. 110k. We still have the sort of carnival-style paper tickets. I would guess that most smaller cities don’t have fancy NFC tickets.
I’m surprised you have a subway at all
We don’t, we have a bus line.
For small cities a bus is better than a subway. There is no traffic so a bus moves fast enough, and roads don't cost that much. You need those roads anyway for trucks, so may as well reuse them. When a city grows close to a million they should start installing metros - but cities have plenty of warning and so should start reserving space for the metro at 500k.