Edit: it's not the archiving that's illegal (probably)--it's the sharing of the archive that is. And sure they can share it after the copyright term runs out, but that's so far in the future the odds of an unmirrored archive surviving are slim.
Edit: and this case drives it home. Copyright makes it illegal to preserve this music history, and the owners don't give a shit.
Also a mandatory CC/NC licensing for some type of content could be a good idea
It's not illegal to archive of course. Video recorders were a thing even back in the day of MTV, completely legal consumer devices.
I think saying that duration isn't a factor is oversimplifying the issue. We'd be relying on multiple independent archivists to all hold individually-obtained copies of the data for nearly 100 years, and none of them would be allowed to transfer the data to anyone else. That's a very different scenario to one where the data were freely mirrorable after 24 years.