Taxing super-rich debate should start with 2% levy, says economist behind plan
uk.finance.yahoo.com
uk.finance.yahoo.com
This would direct cash to dividends which then could get taxed as individual gains...
At a high level, if a company which has taken investment in the past in return for giving up some control of the company, if they have spare cash later it seems reasonable to buy back some of that control. If available control of the company is then more scarce but the demand hasn’t changed, it’s fair that the share price goes up as a result.
People on the internet seem to treat it as a loophole that is being exploited, but I don’t really see that. Should companies never be allowed to roll back share issuance?
The effects of dividends and buybacks are the same but they are taxed differently.
If undilution doesn’t really change the ownership, then logically dilution doesn’t really change the ownership either. That is straightforwardly false, therefore your statement is false.
I understand the Reddit tier surface level analysis and I am questioning that, while you are just parroting it again back at me.
You could seize the full assets of every US Billionaire and it wouldn't cover a single year of the federal budget or dent the debt. There's no way to tax out of this hole... spending cuts need to happen, and restructuring as well. Taxes should focus on points of exchange.
Most Americans have a large portion, if not all of their net worth tied up in their house. This is a very illiquid asset. Yet we have no problem taxing them at around 2%. If regular people can do it, I am sure billionaires will figure out a way to pay too.
I think we'd be better off with exchange taxes. Every time assets, securities, currency, etc is exchanged... it gets taxed. This includes stock trades. Property taxes are a way to make people not actually own their property.
You might have chosen to pay your property taxes monthly, through escrow, and thus 1/12 of your property tax is sent along with your mortgage principal and interest every month, but your actual mortgage numbers aren't changing.
Nobody should have property removed simply for living another year.
edit: property taxes are actually up about 400% over when I bought my home 6 years ago. They property evaluation is now close to market value, where it was much lower/less and historically had been. It's been a money grab. It's also been particularly hard on retired home owners.
I bought my house in 2015 for $340K, it's estimated to be worth $550-600K now, but my property tax is on only $275K in value. Each year, that value goes up 3%. It was taxed based on a ~$210K value when I bought it.
In this case though, "new buyer" will only refer to new construction. A buyer of an existing house keeps the assessed value. It doesn't jump.
That's kind of the point here, isn't it? To the people proposing this, that's a feature, not a bug.
You think it's a bug. Fine. But if you oppose it, saying "but it will actually do what it was designed to do!" is not an effective counterargument.
Yes, you have. You keep repeating it, like you think saying it ends the argument.
The problem that people are trying to address is wealth inequality. They want something that affects the rich more than everyone else - more than linearly. The problem with all your "points of interaction" is that they don't do that. They especially don't touch someone who has 10 billion dollars and just sits on it - leaves it invested in the same thing, maybe for decades, and doesn't spend nearly in proportion to their wealth.
What do you have to say to the people who are trying to address wealth inequality, other than just repeating that you don't think they should do that? Do you have anything that might actually make them change their minds?
How do you figure? What does ownership have to do with taxation?
And there is a liquid market in property at least, for some definition of liquidity, which makes it possible to sell and possible to set some kind of price. Real property also lacks the significant privacy invasion and personal information problems that arise with other kinds of property-- since real property is inherently non-private in some sense (otherwise it's a hole in a map :) ).
For many other kinds of valuable assets there really may be no liquid market and any prices you would ascribe are just pure conjecture and fiction. It may well be difficult for the owner to even know they own it, or what its condition is, without ongoing costly auditing, etc.
I'll grant you that it's a counter argument, but I don't know that it's a good one.
Before someone suggests that a wealth tax could be applied to publicly traded equities that avoided most of these issues-- perhaps, but at the cost of tremendous market distortion as people tried to pull wealth into things other than equities, greatly harming everyone else who isn't hyper rich and doesn't have a lot of investment opportunities outside of the public markets.
Just take a look at the absurd california wealth tax proposals-- the amount of abjectly insane personal invasion required to try to close off escapes requiring billions of dollars in funding while still basically letting some unelected board nail people under suspicious of not paying enough, it's truly remarkable.
One doesn't have to care at all about the pocketbooks of the targets to recognize bad public policy, ripe for corrupt exploitation.
Many localities also are flexible with property taxes for example, letting senior citizens, the disabled, or those with low income freeze their property taxes.
Yes, if we implement a new law badly the results might be bad, but why would we do that? Obviously we would write the legislation carefully to address all such details.
It does not make sense to raise objections that are so trivially addressed. If I invented the automobile would you complain that they are impossible and will never catch on merely because there's no way to see behind you, a complaint easily remedied by adding a cheap mirror?
Here on HN we should focus on more substantive comments
So, you'd need some liquid assets, or to time any lockup to make them available when needed. So maybe you make a slightly less than optimal return on 2% of your wealth > $1B. A tragedy.
> And why over a billion, why not put it at over a million, or ten?
Every limit is arguably arbitrary. The tax codes and laws in general are full of limits that had to be set at some point - misdemeanor vs felony theft, etc.
> You could seize the full assets of every US Billionaire and it wouldn't cover a single year of the federal budget or dent the debt
So if it's less than some arbitrary limit you've just set, there's no point in doing it at all?
> There's no way to tax out of this hole... spending cuts need to happen, and restructuring as well.
Nah https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/19/opinion/government-debt-p... (https://archive.is/uqYiY)
> Taxes should focus on points of exchange.
Yes, increase taxes on the poor for basic necessities rather than taxing people with far more money than they productively use because... ???
> Yes, increase taxes on the poor for basic necessities rather than taxing people with far more money than they productively use because... ???
Yeah, wealthy don't have any major exchanges... no stock trades, no building purchases, no yachts that would vastly exceed the spending of most poor.
Again, my personal preference is not to deprive someone of property for living another year.
It's not worth doing because it's going to distort markets and discourage investment and encourage hiding your wealth.
>Yes, increase taxes on the poor for basic necessities rather than taxing people with far more money than they productively use because... ???
Or maybe stop spending such an insane amount of money on bad government services that don't work?
imagine liquidating all of your assets every month to pay rent. I think the 2% crowd will do just fine.
The OP didn't explain this since it is obvious to most people, and the elite few who don't get this knowledge for free, frankly, have a basic duty to society to learn a little bit about how the other half lives, so that they don't constantly embarrass themselves as you just did, or as Mrs Vanderbilt once famously did when she asked where the gardeners bought the leaves to place on the lawn so artfully (having grown up in an estate where thr servants cleaned up before the family could see them)
I know, I know, living paycheck to paycheck sounds crazy right? Maybe to you or me, but you try living off $13 an hour in a major city and see if you do any better.
Do you always make wild assumptions about anyone that disagrees with you?
You could literally seize all the assets of every Billionaire in the US, and it wouldn't cover a year of the US federal budget. What are you proposing for the year after?
It's not about using their money on federal budget.
It's that money=power, and it's to the detriment of society for any individual to have that much power.
https://www.amazon.com/Limitarianism-Case-Against-Extreme-We...
Billionaires already pay for an extraordinary outsized portion of federal spending, so I don't think that deceptive framing does anything except turn people against your position.
In 2024, the Federal government is projected to borrow $1.9T.
And remember: billionaire wealth is mostly paper wealth. The deficit is real dollars.
We have a spending problem. Not a rich people problem.
Second, the article definitely says "the billionaire minimum income tax proposed in the U.S. by President Joe Biden, which targets individuals with more than $100 million in wealth...would subject the entire pre-tax return on wealth for ultra-high-net-worth Americans to a minimum individual tax rate of 25%, irrespective of whether the return comes from dividends, realized capital gains or unrealized gains". So within the US perhaps it's more reasonable to talk about people with $100M rather than $1B and laugh about the name not exactly matching the number.
I don't have the exact total wealth number for that threshold, but I do have the wealth of the top 0.1% in the US, whose minimum net worth is now about $50M (extrapolate 2 years from https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBLTP1311), which is close enough to $100M for me, at a total of $20.7T (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBLTP1246).
Third, 2% is given as a minimum starting point. Even at 5% the money would still be increasing in the market faster than that.
A tax increase argument on any part of society should be centered around what you are hoping to do with those taxes: reduce borrowing, pay down public debts, increase public services (I should specify: public services which are worth the government keeping people on payroll to perform as a public service). Taxes aren’t an equalizer, they’re a government revenue stream. They’re not always even the best government revenue stream to cover every service, some can be fee-for-service, some can be covered by tariffs.
In terms of benefits, if we’re talking what the Federal budget gets spent on, the largest amounts are usually Social Security and Medicare, but this is non-discretionary (although it still matters!) and discretionary spending is typically topped by HHS and the Military (although not necessarily in that order). I don’t recall what #3 usually is, but I’m pretty sure it’s usually Education. There was also the CARES act, so that might throw some of this off.
So, go on then, flesh out your argument.
The rich benefit disproportionately from societal structure that enforces protections for the rich and restrictions on the poor. The rich do fuck all to benefit from the average growth rate of the market compounding their wealth. Those gains should go foremost to society.
Where are the movements to reign in government? They hardly exist. People are delusional about what is causing their ills. Inflation? Caused by populism, not the rich. But nobody wants to admit that.
Taxing on exchange would disproportionately affect the wealthy but still be fair. Not just income but money exchange. Then when $B buys, sells, shorts stock it's accounted for. When goods and materials are bought or sold, it's taxes. The wealthy buy, sell, trade and rent more than poor. They'd pay more there.
I find taxes on existing property just ethically and morally wrong. I don't care if it's a poor guy's bicycle or a billionaire yacht.
The federal deficit has been skyrocketing every since Reagan massively cut the top marginal rate.
Combine it with crony capitalism, where government contracts go to whoever promises to kick back the most to the politicians' next campaign, "use it or lose it" budgeting that encourages wasteful spending, and we have massive over-spending.
You must recognize that it's a very bad look when a state says "We're going to let poor children starve and cut $X from school lunch programs" and then in the same breath say "We're cutting taxes on 'job creators' by $X".
https://www.cnn.com/2023/12/21/health/nutritional-deficiency...