So Axiom of Choice/Banach-Tarski doesn't really apply in physics since they are only interesting when talking about infinite sets.
So Axiom of Choice/Banach-Tarski doesn't really apply in physics since they are only interesting when talking about infinite sets.
The “no physical infinity” thing sounds like a very Greek sort of axiom — like their “nature abhors a vacuum” thing, etc.
You probably know this, but it's easy to confuse the map (a physical theory) with the territory (reality, which is far more complicated).
And most physicists assume space and time are quantized, we just don't know how.
We have a lot of hints that the amount of information in any given space might be bounded, but yet that space appears continuous. How exactly you reconcile this is (one of) the mystery of quantum gravity.
Interestingly, some great mathematicians (including Grothendieck) thought that modelling space as continuum was an approximation and not the reality.
Sure, we cannot measure infinity, but to be fair, all mathematical concepts (when looked at closely enough) are not something we measure directly.
Even if a kindergarten-level maths of "there are three apples," we do an abstraction. We need to decide that something is a separate object, an apple (how big or small should a fruit be an apple? if there is a bite, is it an apple? etc, etc) - usually with an assumption that all apples are the same (which we know is not true, but serves as an useful approximation). pretend that