You'd need to do more math than that: has the rate of change in prices of those things decreased?
It could be more 10% more expensive but previously would've gotten 15% more expensive, for instance.
And of course even that is trivializing it: there have been outside factors that would also affect the baseline trend in the price of housing for the last 5-10 years, so it could be tough to measure against it.
The authors of the article don't really try: "it's not clear whether the near-ban is achieving one of its central goals: relieving pressure on the city's severe housing shortage."
I had previously been planning yearly trips to visit NYC with friends. For the last 3 years with Airbnb and I was booking 2-4 bedroom places for between 3-6 people. The cost per person per night jumped from ~$75-150 to $150-250 depending on the week. :-O
Have you tried Queens or Brooklyn?
Sorry for being pedantic but I believe this isn't really true.
New York ranks 11th in the world [0], it's not even the most populated in the Americas, nor 2nd.
The alternative of midtown/queens hotels are typically still $200-300, but cost more in travel time/expense.
My gripe here is mainly that before I could plan an outing for group and we could all live in the space and have common areas for eating/relaxing. Even if hotels were the same price, they still are a worse experience than staying in a house/apartment with friends.
Something the post I directly replied to showed confusion about.
[0]: https://marketing.wharton.upenn.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/...
Edit, and by cheaper, I mean less than they would be otherwise. Maybe that's the confusion I'm having.
But Airbnb and other critics say the near-ban won't do much to address the housing crisis and will hurt homeowners who relied on the rental income and visitors who couldn't afford sky-high hotel costs. There is a slew of factors — including new housing construction and migration patterns — that impact housing costs and vacancy rates. But there's some evidence, including from Irvine, California, that restricting short-term rentals can reduce rents. It's not clear how much of a role LL18 has played so far in changing these conditions.
I listed two title snippets, said which was from the article, and said one was from here. That's exceptionally clear.
From what I replied to:
Well, ok, hotels are more expensive now, but are houses and long term rentals any cheaper? Was the ban successful at improving housing affordability for the people who live there?
These questions are answered, as I specifed, by the title.
You.may not like the lack of detail, but that was not the criticism I responded to.
The title says "no, not cheaper".
OP would have been more prudent, if that was the real question, to say "Provides no evidence". It's OK for an article to focus on one thing, in this case, hotel pricing.
AirBnB is located in SF is it not? So so some of the profits flow from NYC to SF.
I get it that hotels too are not Head quartered in NYC so profits leave the city too.
But why support housing for financial gain?