> More time in discussion with an expert could potentially fill in those gaps.
Those gaps were left by the removal, and lack of coverage towards critical thinking and reasoning which normally preceded these classes.
You don't see these issues in cohorts that have received classical education focused on first-principles.
Coverage of Descartes rules of Method; and a priori deduction are mandatory. The trouble these students are having is primarily because they've been taught by rote(authority and dynamics based in Marxism), instead of by rational first principles. Its infected most publicly funded education.
In all fairness, I don't think more time with an 'expert' would fill those gaps, I've personally observed several contradictions where the supposed expert fails to perform as a result of incentives.
Most teachers at that level aren't actually experts. They have their lesson plans, but the moment a problem comes up outside of that (such as when the salt the earth/burning bridges strategy is used between Algebra->Geometry->Trigonometry courses), they'll just enforce a struggle session making the student suffer so unimaginably that they succumb and believe that they simply are not good at math.
The student as a result of that torture (yes it is that) gets PTSD which few ever recover from.
The structure is by systemic design since math is used to gatekeep all hard science and technology. If you can't understand Math, you won't be able to follow any of the subsequent lessons that use it as the primary tool to impart knowledge (eschewing intuitive or deductive understandings or relationships as was previously done pre-1970s).