The last time they didn’t let people know about battery information they were fined heavily, even though it prevented unwanted behaviour (reboots). If a third party battery can’t supply peak current demand, they will have to alert.
And putting DRM on hardware to prevent people using third-party peripherals disempowers the user, and should be illegal.
This is not relevant to this discussion.
I have a preference for OEM parts. Other people can use a third party battery. Given the fire hazard on cheap batteries, I’ll pass.
And how soon before manufacturers move from the first to the second, if they are not stopped by law?
I have no objection to alerts per se, as long as it is done in a non-obnoxious way.
If that wasn’t legal, then I’d want to at least log it. That way when someone claims my product burned down their house, I would have proof that it wasn’t my battery that did it.
This isn’t bullet proof however- if you are a big enough company the media headlines will still have your product in the headline, and you’d be lucky if the main body mentioned the manufacturer of the fault-causing component.
A few years back when phone batteries were almost always replaceable anyway, when buying replacement batteries you'd have expensive genuine batteries, expensive fake batteries, cheap fake batteries. It almost always made sense to buy the cheap fake ones knowing you might have to replacement them again sooner, than pay for the expensive one only to find it was exactly the same as the cheap one anyway.
I kind of think if there's DRM, the market will gravitate more towards expensive fake rather than cheap fake.
lovely how people throw away a working system that prevents this problem and returns us to the path of e-waste, while opposing even the idea of notifying the user about fake parts, all ostensibly in the name of preventing e-waste.