I would however hesitate to call him an anarchist after hearing his comments about the unvaccinated during Covid.
I would however hesitate to call him an anarchist after hearing his comments about the unvaccinated during Covid.
In fact, in this interview, he declares opposition to a vaccine mandate, and doesn't even call for social shunning - he instead suggests that the unvaccinated should take it upon themselves to self-isolate. https://www.independent.co.uk/tv/news/noam-chomsky-calls-for...
Even though I am vaccinated, I personally reject calls for medical discrimination and violations of bodily autonomy. I think it is one thing for individuals to make choices and decide who they want to invite to their house. But I think it is another thing entirely for public or private employers or other places to ban people on such traits.
Whether it is forced by the government or not, doesn’t make a difference to me. But I will also note that the line can be very blurry to begin with. For example, many cities have public transportation that is operated by private entities.
If you are an anarchist, and you truly feel that McDonald's hierarchy is just as problematic as governments coercing behavior, OK, you do you.
But if you're not an anarchist, and you're arguing anarchists think this way... that is not the way any of my anarchist friends think about the problems of corporate hegemony vs. government coercion.
They are against both, but consider them vastly different problems, in scope as well as kind. Juxtaposing them and saying there's no difference... is not what any anarchists I know would do.
This came up in a conversation where we were talking about various charities we might do something for, and since there was a Ronald McDonald House charity office nearby, I had suggested it.
The mere association with McDonald's corporate made it entirely unacceptable.
Basically, he wants everyone to be ideal, and if they don't fit his ideal, they should be compelled.
This view is no different than any other tyrannical regime, in that regard; what dictator or oppressive group wouldn't want the entire populace to be completely compliant with their demands?
Specifically, I don't think he considered the degree to which people in power would lie about what they knew about the actual characteristics of the disease to such an extent, which means that he had fallen out of touch with his own work.
edit: Covid being as weak as it was was just luck. The next disease could be almost the same, let's say like MERS with a possible 35% fatality rate, but with a long asymptomatic incubation time during which people are at their most infectious. If that happens, we'll still have to grapple with the questions that Chomsky dared to give answers to.