But I think I can say with confidence that none of those fields care about the fact that hitting a rational number out of the reals has probability 0. If they do something's wrong.
Edit: oh wow your reply got a lot longer after I responded
But I think I can say with confidence that none of those fields care about the fact that hitting a rational number out of the reals has probability 0. If they do something's wrong.
Edit: oh wow your reply got a lot longer after I responded
Let's say we play a game, we uniformly pick a random real between 0 and 1 and you win if it is rational, I win if it is not.
You can obviously see that it is unfair, but how do you prove it? You need a concept of integration that can easily ignore a dense set of discontinuities, Riemann integration is not going to give you any good results (in this case at the very best it would tell you that you win between 0% and 100% of the times, not very useful)
Measure theory and Lebesgue integration are a way to discard this noise.
Actually in measure theory you generally use L¹, L², etc spaces where functions are defined modulo null sets; that is the function that is 1 on rational and 0 on irrationals is considered to be the same function as the constant 0.
In measure theory on the Reals the value of a function at a specific point is generally considered irrelevant.
I suspect that in both physics and economics you might end up using stochastic methods that use concepts and techniques similar to those of measure theory
Physics are very good at working with concepts and abstraction before any formal mathy justifications can be found, but the only way to formaly work with a dirac delta that makes sense formally is defining it in terms of measures
Actually an even better way to think of delta functions is just as a geometric object, a point (or line/plane/etc). Which is somewhat related to the measure theoretic version, but much more simple to think about.
Not that it would be impossible to define everything without measures (or even without real numbers), but it's really not clear how to go about it.
Zeroes and infinities are problematic in physics. Physics and math aren’t the same discipline, and it’s dangerous to conflate them.
I’m pretty sure there will be a point where you’ll have a light-emitting superconductor on your way to an infinite current.