https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25162652/#:~:text=Caloric%20....
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25162652/#:~:text=Caloric%20....
Until relatively recently(20 years) studies have been measuring the wrong thing, assuming metabolism is flexible and follows activity.
Studies measuring actual energy expenditure (using methods like double labelled water) confirmed, counterintuitively, that adjusted for weight, lean mass and age, people have roughly the same metabolic rate regardless of activity.
It's an evolutionary adaptation for periods of low food availability - the body does everything it can to not touch those fat stores.
Here's a podcast with one of the researchers who studied this:
https://theproof.com/rethinking-diet-exercise-with-herman-po...
The gist is that he went to a modern hunter-gatherer community, studied their activities and measured their energy expenditure. To his incredulity, the results indicated that these very active people use as much energy as their sedentary counterparts living in civilisation.
Initial conclusion was that there must have been a mistake somewhere, but the same measurement using a different method yielded the same results.
Similar studies on rats showed that increased activity reduces processes like inflammation, healing of wounds and production of reproductive hormones like estrogen.
Essentially our digestive systems are already doing their best.
There was an additional study in cooperation with several zoos which showed that other primates work the same. Humans have actually a pretty active metabolism in comparison, as it burns an average of 400kcal more.
Also it's not just this study. Research on this actually started in the 1980s when the double labelled water method became practical - unfortunately it's still massively expensive.
All in all there's a much larger body of research indicating that exercise is not effective at controlling weight. The Hadza study at least gives some clues and indicates that there's something we're missing and this mechanistic approach to metabolism where you can just coax it into burning more is a model that doesn't reflect reality.