You know it’s funny but my math professor in high school had the same argument when I modeled a calculus problem in my computer to arrive at the answer numerically instead of analytically.
In elementary school calculators were banned because “students arent learning anything”
Then in high school and college Wikipedia was banned because “students arent learning anything, they’re just looking up facts”
But by end of college open laptop exams were popular because doing fast research during an exam is good actually.
Is writing repetitive uninsightful essays nobody wants to read a useful skill for humans?
PS: graphing calculators were super banned in high school, even after we started being allowed calculators. I hear these days graphing calculators are required. Progress marches on
As evidence I submit ChatGPT’s own waffly style of writing. It learned that from humans who on average are poor communicators. The “high school/college essay” style of writing is something new employees have to actively unlearn in their first few years in the workforce.
edit: If I was a teacher right now, I would give my students a 2000 word essay written by ChatGPT on $topic and ask them to redline the printout. This teaches them the actually useful skill of editing and fact checking since it looks like producing words has become commoditized.
ChatGPT has a "waffly" style of writing because it is incapable of thinking, it's simply trying to predict the next word.
If you learned good/effective communications skills from high school essays, kudos! I did not, but I did enjoy the process and writing essays was one of my fav activities in school. Just that the “effective” part came way later :)
Let's try to ensure that no one else has to learn in a substandard environment instead of abandoning teaching kids how to write and communicate and replace it with something that can never do it as well as a human.
It absolutely has not
Producing good words not so much.
People who want to cheat will always find ways to cheat. But if you genuinely want to learn something new then LLMs make it an order of magnitude easier, because they tell you exactly where to start, which resources to consider, giving you completely tailored answers to your problem or project, even if they're still oftentimes wrong. Google being increasingly useless in recent years also didn't help things.
I would not be surprised if in 20 years multimodal models are the main way to for most people to learn. There's always a lack of teachers, they're underpaid and forced to deal with an increasing amount of parent bullshit, half of them don't even have a good grasp of the topics they're teaching or just no longer give a fuck. Eventually there simply won't be enough of them and a personalized automated solution will just be better and cheaper. College professors? Probably in 10 years already and both them and the students will be happier for it, the former that can now finally focus on research and the latter for actually having a competent tutor instead of someone who has no aptitude for it but is forced to do it regardless.
Since when is writing essays and getting expert feedback pointless if you want to learn how to write?
> There's always a lack of teachers, they're underpaid
So rather than prioritizing teaching we should conduct a moonshot project to build a homeschooling technonanny that uses enough electricity to power the Eastern Seaboard so we can educate our kids without human interaction?
> we should conduct a moonshot project to build a homeschooling technonanny that uses enough electricity to power the Eastern Seaboard so we can educate our kids without human interaction
Actually, unironically yes since you only have to do pretraining once. A model that can then run inference locally on smartphones and is used for many years would amortize its creation cost though the utility it provides in a few years. It wouldn't even have to be AGI tier, just good enough to work with.
A single teacher educating 30 people vastly underperforms 1-1 tutoring. It's a "good enough" system and it doesn't work very well for most people, it's just the only thing we have. Hell most of it is just following a fixed script that repeats every year, answering a few questions and grading based on ground truth.
A personalized teaching system that knows your interests and skills would be able to motivate and explain far more effectively by adapting the script to you in pace and difficulty. Being available to you 24/7 for questions and having a personality you like would certainly help too. There's this 11 year old video [0] from the ex-teacher CGP Grey that turned out to be pretty prescient and elaborates a bit more on the general idea.
All of this could even be done sustainably, running training during peak solar hours, excess wind power and the like, but as long as there's demand it doesn't make sense to leave your expensive and rapidly depreciating GPUs idle. And there's demand because people have this misconceived notion that AGI is somehow winner take all, making it a race where everyone's flailing about like a headless chicken. In reality whoever gets there first will have a short first mover advantage for half a year and then everyone else will replicate their work, and probably an open source version a year and a half later tops.