(in fact, IMX from last century's US, rich people there are more paranoid than poor about their offspring's ability to function as independent members of their society)
High-trust societies pay off in ways that don't tend to show up if one's only measure is GDP.
If Tories had been half as serious about "levelling up" as they'd claimed, we'd also see a lot less poverty in 2024 UK than there was in 2010.
(and norway ranks below ireland and luxemburg for GDP/capita)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Financial_Centres_Index...
* recall: Brexit was sold on the premise that the UK would get even richer outside the EU.
I think this is where we're arguing at cross purposes.
I don't see heaps of disposable income having much to do with free range parenting: it's cheaper, after all, to let your kids organise their own activities than to be endlessly shuttling them between formal paid activities.
That said, the flip side of it being cheaper is that you can't just go out and buy a high-trust country even if you want to and have disposable income; you have to give everyone the experience that it's much nicer to live someplace where things don't just sprout legs and walk away if you leave them unattended.
Those experiences don't cost anything, but getting there takes work, and while I think the US and UK would be willing to spend a lot of legal tender to "fix social issues", neither polity seems willing to get there by paying their dues instead.
Maybe not directly. But indirectly it has a huge effect on the overall well-being of your society and thus the things you can or can't do. Or do you believe that Norwegians would still behave the same way if they had income inequality similar to less fortunate countries? Because I don't see any evidence for that.
(that is: if you set out to make a society where "free range" parenting works, you will naturally also reduce income inequality; if you set out to make a society where middle class workers have to be kept motivated by fear of falling into a –reputedly or truly— crime-ridden underclass, you probably won't wind up with one suitable for what I would consider normal parenting)
That is an extremely bold assumption that has zero evidence. In fact, if you look at income inequality around the world, you'll see other factors are infinitely more important.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...
Not even accounting for Berkson's paradox yet (patience pls!), let's set Japan's gini as fiducial for free range parenting countries?
Possible outliers: south Korea, hk (see also my comment below while initiating consideration of Berkson)
Interesting datapoints: Ukraine, Iraq, pakistan
To get an idea of the level of discourse we should be aiming for, how about we investigate those interesting datapoints to find out if we should consider median (non-extensive) PPP as a proxy for parenting free-rangedness♥
Let's revisit this conversation in 20 years' time when Pakistan has leapfrogged India. Keeping my fingers crossed for Ukraine
Don't feel sorry, that's arrogance too :)
More productively, how do you think your hypotheses differs from mine? All I'm saying here is, the question of how to find data in the world to answer the question of whether reducing inequality improves trust in society deserves attention and interest.
Don't just stop at the null hypothesis? Cynicism means, waiting for data to reveal itself, even in absence of any nonnullhypothesis. Quite (median) physicist, to be fair?
You also don't have to assume the null hypothesis that I am not like you :)
Tbh this seems like a huge waste of time for any conversation, so you'll have to excuse me if I disengage here.
Similar practices exist in many cultures. If they're trying to influence Britain, then comparing to Norway is probably far more effective than some more-distant culture.
I'm vaguely aware of stories about young children in huge Japanese (& maybe Chinese) cities having similar independence, and of the "Old Enough!" Japanese reality show...but perhaps other HNer's could speak to that.
Sorry but you read an article in "The Guardian" about how to parent like one of the wealthiest and privileged nations in Europe and you take this as "general advice". THAT is laughable and stupid.
Most of the stuff in this article that is touted as this utopian freedom for kids is what I strongly associate with poverty around the world.
Taking yourself to and back from school? Taking care of yourself because there is nobody else to do it? Spending time outside because you don't want to stay home? Sounds more like every "black teenager in the projects" story I've ever seen on TV.
Sure, it sucks harder for poor people. So rich people shouldn't give their kids the chance to grow up as real people and learn independence? If you can afford a golden cage, lock your kids up? I don't understand that reasoning.