What about BSL, SSPL, or other source available (for your eyes only) licenses? Copilot harvests all public repos, regardless of its license.
What about BSL, SSPL, or other source available (for your eyes only) licenses? Copilot harvests all public repos, regardless of its license.
To simplify:
- imagine all code Copilot trained on is GPL licensed. - we have a universal function `isInfringing(code)` that has access to all GPL code, and returns `true` if it is infringing some GPL code.
for a given prompt; if `isInfringing(copilot(prompt))==false` we cannot claim copilot infringing on GPL code, even it is trained on GPLed code.
so the problem starts here; does the piece of code copilot emits, if written by yourself also would be infringing ?
why everyone on discussions tries to bring "if a human made it"? a generative AI operates way faster than anyone ever existed and ever will and probably a person aware of the license & acting respectful towards it, will create something more sensible/plausible to avoid plagiarism
now having dozen/hundreds/thousands of humans substituted by a machine that makes money for some for-profit company is really fair? even if they were a non-profit, as someone pointed up, people who create the content that feeds the weights aren't recieving a penny! they already made money with it, they will make more & that is/will upgrading/e the state of gen. AI
for sure legal battles on people copying code from permissive licenses should exist but it's feels a different discussion
At what measure is one sufficiently inspired for it to be a derivate work? That is up to courts to decide.
Technically when you get a piece from each, there is no infringement legally. ( as they have all different copyright holders )
If CoPilot indeed derives a function (or a functional block) from a single source, it might plainly violate the license of the repository where it derives the code from.
There are many questions, and nothing is clear cut. The only thing I know is, I will never use that thing.
EDIT: I remembered that people were able to make CoPilot emit their code almost as-is with the correct prompts: https://x.com/docsparse/status/1581461734665367554
So it's not we're taking a bit from n different sources, and generate something with that.
False in ex-Commonwealth countries and Japan.