The null hypothesis has to be that the number of interesting and important open research problems in mathematics is expanding without limit. If the author thinks that's not the case it's up to them to actually justify their position rather than just blandly state it with a "No true Scotsman" addition that the number of problems that are interesting to "a fair number of people" is diminishing on the basis that they find "The Journal of Algebra" to contain things that are not interesting to them.
Most mathematicians I know seem accutely aware that the field of mathematics as a serious intellectual endeavour is over 3000 years old at this point and therefore are aware of its maturity as a field.