I have worked at places which controlled the roll-out of new security updates (and windows updates) for this very reason. If you invest enough in IT is possible. But you have to have a lot of money to invest in IT to have people good enough to manage it. If you can get SwiftOnSecurity to manage your network, you can have that. But can every hospital, doctor's office, pharmacy, scan center, etc. get top tier talent like SwiftOnSecurity?
Healthcare IT is very important, because computers are good at record-keeping, retrieval and storage, and that's a huge part of healthcare.
When it came to audit time, the auditors were always impressed that our team had better timely updates than the corporate office side of things.
I never really thought we were doing anythin all that special (in fact, there were always many things I wanted to improve anout the process) but reading about this issue makes me think that maybe we really were just that much better than the average IT shop?
But did they also control the roll-out of virus/threat definition files? Because if not their goose would have been still cooked this time.
If, for example, they were doing slow rollouts for configs in addition to binaries, they could have caught the problem in their canary/test envs and not let it proceed to a full blackout.
The fact that ransomware is still a concern is an indication that we've failed to update our IT management and design appropriately to account for them. We took the cheap way out and hoped a single vendor could just paper over the issue. Never in history has this ever worked.
Also speaking of generators a large enough hospital should be running power failure test events periodically. Why isn't a "massive IT failure test event" ever part of the schedule? Probably because they know they have no reasonable options and any scale of catastrophe would be too disastrous to even think about testing.
It's a lesson on the failures of monoculture. We've taken the 1970s design as far as it can ago. We need a more organically inspired and rigorous approach to systems building now.